Shawn Wilbur argues that âanarchyâ and âdemocracyâ are completely distinct principlesâphilosophically. Philosophically, there is âno middle ground.â However, in actual living, there is âthe likelihood that we might continue to have recourse to practices that we think of as âdemocratic.â It is difficult to imagine a society in which we are not at times forced toâŠengage in practices like voting.â How often will these times happen? Perhaps a lot during the âtransitionâ from statism to anarchy.Â
Shawn seems to want to have his cake and eat it too. He fiercely rejects even the most decentralized, direct, participatory, democracy in the name of anarchism (philosophically). This is combined with a willingness to support actual democratic procedures in solving collective problems (practically). Â
Let us leave aside philosophical definitions, as well as considerations of what Proudhon and Bakunin really meant (although Bakuninâs anarchist association called itself the Alliance of Socialist Democracy). Does Shawn really disagree with me and other democratic anarchists, in praxis (integrating theory and practice)? He and I are both for as much freedom as possible, both individual and collectiveârejecting the state and any other institution of oppression. We both want collective decisions to be as free and uncoerced as is possible. We both accept that there have to be some conflicts in which everyone is not satisfied with the outcome, conflicts which must be managed through democratic procedures of some sort (even if he compares this to cannibalism!). If we can agree on this much, then I am willing to accept that we have differences in philosophy.
Gabriel Amadej also bases her argument on principles developed by Proudhon. Unlike Shawn Wilbur, her solution to collective decisionmaking is not through democratic procedures but through âthe market.â But our societies are so intertwined and interconnected, economically and otherwise, that even decentralization will not end the need for working and living together collectivelyâand making collective decisions in our workplaces and communitiesâdemocracy.
Mutual Exchange is C4SSâs goal in two senses: We favor a society rooted in peaceful, voluntary cooperation, and we seek to foster understanding through ongoing dialogue. Mutual Exchange will provide opportunities for conversation about issues that matter to C4SSâs audience.
Online symposiums will include essays by a diverse range of writers presenting and debating their views on a variety of interrelated and overlapping topics, tied together by the overarching monthly theme. C4SS is extremely interested in feedback from our readers. Suggestions and comments are enthusiastically encouraged. If youâre interested in proposing topics and/or authors for our program to pursue, or if youâre interested in participating yourself, please email C4SSâs Mutual Exchange Coordinator, Cory Massimino, at cory.massimino@c4ss.org.






