
GTX 1080TiとQwen Image 2.1で絵巻物画像生成
chakkun1121です。今回は最近出てきたQwen Image 2.1で絵巻物画像を生成してみました。
利用したパソコンは前購入した7万円のやつです。
詳細スペックは以下の記事に書きましたが、ざっとこんな感じです。
RAM: 64GB (DDR4)
GPU: GTX 1080 Ti (VRAM 11GB)
OS: Ubuntu 26.04 LTS (Windows11が入らないから投げ売りされていた)
まずそのままやってみる
まずはプロンプトも工夫せずに実行してみました。
emakimono

なんでこうなる? 指示が悪いのもあるが、それだけじゃないな。GPT Image 2/2.5, NanoBanana 2/Pro だとこれぐらい雑なプロンプトでも(ツッコミどころ満載だが)まだまともな画像が出てくるぞ
あと回しているときにVRAMが10.5GB程度使っていました。これUbuntuだからギリギリ回り切りましたが、Windowsだと辛いかもな。あと何度か連続して実行しようとしておそらくVRAMが解放されない状態で実行しようとしたら落ちました...。最後にi2iもやりましたが、そこでも10.5GBぐらいでギリギリでした。
プロンプトを改良
ここでGeminiにプロンプトを作ってもらいました。
これを添付して、
日本の絵巻物の画像を出力するプロンプトを書いて。ただしjson出力の指示を無視してプロンプト本体だけを出力して
The image is a wide Yamato-e style illustration of an unrolled Japanese handscroll, resting horizontally across a dark polished lacquered wooden surface. The background surrounding the scroll is a dark, neutral tabletop, providing strong contrast to the warm cream-colored handscroll. On the far left side of the frame, a wooden roller spool wrapped in deep indigo silk brocade with gilded thread patterns sits slightly elevated above the wood. The scroll itself unrolls across the center of the image, revealing an ancient paper surface crafted from textured hand-made washi with visible plant fibers and subtle age spots. In the upper-left region of the visible scroll, three vertical columns of dark black brush calligraphy appear rendered in delicate running script. Surrounding the painted scene in the upper-left and lower-left, shimmering gold-leaf scalloped cloud forms, typical of classical Japanese narrative art, partially veil the landscape background. In the mid-left portion of the painting, an open-sided Heian court pavilion made of cedar wood is depicted, housing three seated figures wearing elaborate layered silk garments in muted crimson, pale moss green, and soft ivory. Beside the figures, a low wooden table holds a small ceramic tea vessel and a rolled manuscript. In the center of the frame, a blooming cherry blossom tree with delicate light pink blossoms arcs over a mossy garden courtyard, where small fallen petals rest on the ground plane. To the right of the center, two attendants dressed in simple charcoal-grey robes walk along a fine gravel path leading toward an ornate wooden gate. In the upper-right area, soft indigo and sage-green washes form distant rolling hills that gradually fade into misty negative space. Along the top and bottom edges of the paper, thin protective silk borders in warm terracotta and navy trim the scroll horizontally. On the far right edge of the frame, the unrolled wooden end of the scroll lies flat against the dark lacquer surface. The lighting is soft and diffused from above, casting subtle shadows under the rolled edges and highlighting the tactile grain of the parchment paper and metallic sheen of the gold foil accents. The overall composition is harmonious and narrative-focused, featuring a muted natural color palette, asymmetrical balance, and the nostalgic atmosphere of classical Japanese scroll art.
Jsonで吐いてきましたが、ここではそのプロンプト部分のみを抽出しています。やはり最初の指示のほうが強かったのですかね?

右側は軸みたいなものが見えるが、ギリギリ太巻きってことで許そう。ただなんで右側の裏面は装飾されていないのに左側は装飾されているの?
参考: 絵巻物の構造
私が研究で使っている鳥獣戯画甲巻の原寸大簡易複製の動画です。本物と違い、しっかりと表装したものではありませんが、軸などの付け方は実物同様です。扱い方については現在の方法ではなく、当時と同じだと思われる方法でやっています。
もう一回再試行。

何故軸が両側に出てくるとかの問題があるのでGeminiでプロンプトを作り直しました
The image is a wide traditional watercolor and ink illustration of an ancient Japanese horizontal handscroll, resting flat on a dark polished wooden surface. Across the top and bottom edges of the frame, the scroll features silk brocade borders woven with delicate gold and deep indigo thread. On the far left side, a turned dark wooden roller spindle is visible where the scroll unrolls, revealing aged cream-colored handmade washi paper scattered with subtle gold leaf flecks. Moving into the main scene from left to right, a serene Heian-period courtyard unfolds beneath weeping cherry blossom trees with soft pink petals cascading gently onto mossy garden pathways. In the central region of the frame, several Heian court nobles wearing elaborate layered silk robes of crimson, sage green, and lavender sit quietly inside an open wooden pavilion fitted with bamboo blinds and woven tatami mats. To the right of the pavilion, a gentle winding stream flows around smooth grey river stones toward distant misty mountains rendered in soft grey and indigo ink washes. Near the top right corner, a column of traditional calligraphic Japanese text written in fluid black ink reads "絵巻物物語". Soft, uniform ambient daylight illuminates the scene evenly, accentuating the fine brushwork, golden dust accents, and natural paper fiber texture. The overall composition is harmonious and expansive, conveying a tranquil narrative mood with a rich historic palette and exquisite classical Japanese aesthetics.

軸は直ったみたいです。ただ上下に余白をつけたがる、更に装飾したがるのは治りません。現在の国宝の作品で上下に表装がある絵巻物作品は見たことがありません(修理の際に本紙が傷まないようにするために余白をつけることは多いが、装飾はしない)
軸いらない。横長の作品の一部にして
The image is a wide traditional watercolor and ink illustration depicting a detailed horizontal section of a classical Japanese handscroll painting, set against textured, cream-colored handmade paper. Soft mist-like bands of gold dust drift across the top edge of the frame, creating an ethereal upper atmosphere. On the far left side, towering pine trees with scuffed dark bark stand beside a weeping cherry tree whose pale pink petals cascade onto a mossy green ground plane. In the upper-left background, distant mountain silhouettes appear as soft grey-blue ink washes fading gently into the mist. In the central region of the frame, an open-sided wooden pavilion built from dark lacquer or stained timber sits elevated on a veranda. Inside the pavilion, several Heian-period court figures wearing rich, multi-layered silk robes of deep crimson, muted olive, and iris purple are engaged in quiet conversation. In the lower-third directly in front of the structure, a shallow winding stream flows toward the right over rounded river stones, rendered in light cyan ink strokes. Across the right side of the frame, a moss-covered stone lantern sits partly obscured by vibrant Japanese maple branches with fiery red foliage. Near the upper-right corner, a neat vertical column of brush-drawn Japanese calligraphy reads "絵巻物物語". The lighting is soft and completely diffused throughout the scene, offering flat, even illumination without harsh directional shadows, accentuating the fine line work and golden paper accents. The overall composition is balanced and panoramic, capturing a tranquil narrative moment with a rich historical palette and exquisite classical Yamato-e aesthetics.

壁のぶち抜き方がなんかおかしいです。てかこれ清明上河図とかでよく見られるものではないでしょうか?

あとこの富士山(もどき)の描き方は明らかに水墨画ですね。これは室町時代以降流行ったものです。
平安時代の作品の画風にしたい。一部水墨画の画風が混ざっているが、これ室町時代以降だから平安時代の作品ではちゃんと輪郭線が描かれる感じだぞ。
The image is a wide Yamato-e style illustration depicting a horizontal scene from an authentic Heian-period handscroll, painted on textured cream-colored paper with crisp black ink outlines and flat mineral pigments. Across the top and bottom edges of the frame, stylized golden cloud bands with scalloped, defined borders frame the visual space instead of misty ink gradients. In the upper-left background, rolling mountain peaks are rendered with prominent black ink contour lines filled with opaque azurite blue and malachite green pigments, dotted with small pine trees drawn in detailed line work. In the central region, a Heian shinden-zukuri palace interior is shown using the fukinuki yatai technique with the roof cut away to reveal the interior from a high vantage point. Within the pavilion, several noblewomen in opulent multi-layered silk robes, including deep crimson and pale lavender jūnihitoe, sit on woven tatami mats; their faces are rendered in the traditional hikime kagihana style with simple ink slits for eyes and small hooks for noses. Every garment fold, architectural beam, and sliding paper screen is sharply delineated by fine black ink line art filled with opaque, flat color. In the lower-third foreground, a shallow winding stream with distinct black line borders flows over rounded river stones painted in solid light turquoise pigment. Along the right side of the frame, weeping cherry blossom trees feature intricate black branch outlines holding clusters of flat pink petals, standing beside a woven bamboo garden fence. The lighting is completely flat and even across the frame, lacking cast shadows or light gradients, which emphasizes the rich decorative color blocks and precise contour lines. The overall composition is harmonious, ornate, and strictly classical, faithfully capturing the iconic two-dimensional aesthetic and vibrant palette of Heian-period Japanese art.

屋根がちゃんとぶち抜かれました。あと見た感じ並行投射は守れたっぽいです。
ただ平安の絵巻物作品では建物の横のラインはほぼ水平になっています(そうじゃない作品の方が珍しいと思う)
例: 年中行事絵巻

他にも掲載はしませんが、信貴山縁起絵巻のすべての建物、伴大納言絵巻もおそらくほぼ全てが平行になっています。
例外: 源氏物語絵巻 寄生木(三)

これは例外ですが、私の絵巻物の定義から外れているし…
この定義も連続式、段落式絵巻の定義がはっきりとしていなかった(というのか8:1というマジックナンバーが含まれていた)ので修正しました。これについては順次電子書籍の方に反映させていきます。
まあ例外もありますが、私が知っている中では多くは平行になっています。
The image is a wide Yamato-e style illustration depicting a horizontal section of an authentic Heian-period Japanese handscroll, painted with crisp black ink outlines and flat mineral pigments on light cream paper. Across the top and bottom edges of the frame, solid gold cloud bands with scalloped, sharply defined borders frame the composition horizontally. In the upper-left background, gentle mountain peaks drawn with clean black contour lines are filled with opaque azurite blue and malachite green pigments. In the central region, a grand Heian shinden-zukuri palace building extends across the frame, its long wooden lintels, floorboards, tatami edges, and veranda railings rendered as strictly horizontal lines parallel to the top and bottom edges of the frame. The palace is depicted using the traditional fukinuki yatai technique, where the roof and ceiling are entirely omitted to reveal the interior rooms from an elevated perspective while all structural pillars and horizontal beams remain intact. Inside these open-topped rooms, several court nobles wearing elaborate silk garments—including multi-layered crimson and pale purple jūnihitoe—sit gracefully, their facial features rendered in the classic hikime kagihana style with simple ink lines for eyes and hooked noses. Every garment fold, tatami weave, and wooden post is sharply defined by uniform black ink lines filled with flat color blocks. In the lower-third foreground, a shallow winding garden stream bounded by black outline borders flows past smooth grey stones over flat turquoise water. On the far right side of the frame, weeping cherry blossom trees with fine black ink branches and flat pink petals stand alongside a woven bamboo fence. The lighting is completely flat and shadowless throughout the frame, eliminating highlights and cast shadows to emphasize the crisp line art and opaque decorative pigments. The overall composition is balanced, orderly, and highly stylized, capturing the precise geometric alignment and vibrant, flat aesthetic of classical Heian handscroll painting.

画角が戻りやがりました。いい加減にしろ。
今度は画角違う。もう少し上の方からみる
The image is a wide Yamato-e style illustration depicting a steep high-angle bird's-eye perspective of a horizontal section from an authentic Heian-period Japanese handscroll, painted on light cream paper with sharp black contour lines and flat mineral pigments. Across the top and bottom edges of the frame, heavy golden cloud bands with scalloped, sharply defined borders partially frame the scene from a high overhead viewpoint. In the central region of the frame, looking down at a steep diagonal angle into a grand Heian shinden-zukuri palace, all long wooden lintels, tatami mat borders, veranda railings, and floor planks are rendered as strictly horizontal lines parallel to the frame edges. The palace uses the authentic fukinuki yatai technique, where the roof and ceiling are completely removed to reveal the floor plans and interior rooms from above while all supporting pillars and screen frames remain standing. Inside these open-topped rooms, viewed from high above, several court nobles wearing elaborate silk garments—including multi-layered crimson and lavender jūnihitoe—sit gracefully, their facial features depicted in the minimal hikime kagihana style with thin ink lines for eyes and hooked noses. In the lower-third foreground directly below the veranda, the courtyard surface spreads out to show a shallow garden stream bounded by crisp black outline borders flowing over flat turquoise water past smooth grey stones. On the far right side, weeping cherry trees with delicate black ink branches and flat pink blossoms are seen from a top-down perspective beside a woven bamboo garden fence. The lighting is entirely flat and shadowless across the frame, emphasizing the crisp line art, geometric horizontal alignment, and vibrant blocks of opaque pigment. The overall composition is balanced, decorative, and highly stylized, capturing the iconic steep bird's-eye vantage point and rich two-dimensional aesthetic of classical Heian handscroll painting.

もうだめだ…
今度は並行じゃなくなったが、これプロンプト、画像生成モデルどっちが悪いの?
結論から言うと、プロンプト内の表現の衝突と画像生成モデルの構造的な弱点の両方に原因があります。
主な理由は以下の2点です。
1. プロンプト側の原因(指示の衝突)
直前のプロンプトに含まれていた steep diagonal angle(急な斜めのアングル) という言葉が原因です。
AIモデルは diagonal(斜め)という単語に強く影響を受け、「カメラ自体を斜めに傾けた立体的な俯瞰ショット」として解釈してしまいます。その結果、同時に指定した strictly horizontal lines(厳密な水平線)という指示と命令が喧嘩し、カメラの傾きが優先されて横のラインが斜めに歪んでしまいました。
2. 画像生成モデル側の原因(学習データの偏り)
現在の画像生成AI(MidjourneyやStable Diffusionなど)は、現実の写真や3Dグラフィック(1点・2点透視図法などの3Dパースペクティブ)を大量に学習しています。
そのため、AIは「俯瞰(high angle / bird's-eye)」と指示されると、自動的にカメラのアングルを傾けて遠近感(消失点)をつけようとする習性があります。
平安絵巻の吹き抜き屋台に見られる「横のラインは完全な水平を保ちつつ、奥行きだけが斜め上に向かう(斜向平行投影・軸測投影)」という2D日本画特有の空間表現は、AIが最も再現を苦手とする構図の一つです。
解決策
AIにカメラの傾きだと誤解させずに「上からの視点」と「水平ライン」を両立させるには、カメラアングル(diagonal / angle)に関する言葉を外し、建築図面や2Dイラストで使われる投影法(Projection)の用語に置き換える必要があります。
削除すべき言葉: diagonal angle, bird's-eye perspective(カメラの傾きや透視パースを誘発するため)
追加・強調すべき言葉: isometric projection(等軸測投影)、parallel projection(平行投影)、flat 2D orthographic elevated view(フラットな2D高所視点)
よく見たら思いっきり誤解しているな。ただこれ以上やっても無理な気がする…。
てか今更ですが、なんか色の感じ違わないか?まず雲がこれ明らかに室町時代以降のものになっているぞ。
通勤電車の様子の生成
次に今までやっていた通勤電車の様子を生成しました。
まず下図なし(Geminiに参考画像として添付)して生成してみました。

The image is a wide Yamato-e style illustration depicting a horizontal section of a modern Japanese commuter train rendered as a classical Heian-period handscroll, painted on textured cream paper with crisp black ink outlines and flat mineral pigments. Across the top and bottom edges of the frame, solid golden cloud bands with scalloped, sharply defined borders frame the composition horizontally. The scene is rendered using a flat 2D elevated parallel projection, where all horizontal lines of the train floor, wall edges, and window frames remain strictly horizontal and parallel to the frame edges. The train carriage is drawn using the authentic fukinuki yatai technique, with its roof and ceiling completely omitted to reveal the interior from an elevated view, while both the front long wall in the foreground and the rear long wall in the background remain intact with their sliding doors and glass windows. Inside the roofless carriage, crowded modern Japanese commuters—salarymen in dark suits, students, and passengers holding smartphones—sit side-by-side on long bench seats or stand in the central aisle holding overhead hanging straps. All figures are drawn in the traditional hikime kagihana style with delicate ink lines for eyes and small hooks for noses, framed by sharp contour lines and flat color fills. Along the lower third, the front wall shows silver train doors and lower panels, while the rear wall displays a sequence of rectangular windows set against a plain pale sky. The lighting is completely flat and shadowless throughout the frame, accentuating the precise black line art and opaque pigment blocks. The overall composition is balanced, graphic, and highly stylized, seamlessly blending modern commuting culture with the iconic architectural conventions of Heian handscroll painting.



明らかに一点透視図法に引っ張られています。あとドア位置おかしいし、内部構造どうなっているんだろうか? 3枚目は結構惜しいですが、でもだめです…。
あと上下の雲なに?大和絵ってひとくくりにして適当に学習しやがったな。
Image to Image(i2i)
次に下図を渡してそれをもとに生成してもらいました。
The image is a wide Yamato-e style illustration depicting a horizontal section of a modern Japanese commuter train rendered as a classical Heian-period handscroll, painted on textured cream paper with crisp black ink outlines and flat mineral pigments. Across the top and bottom edges of the frame, solid golden cloud bands with scalloped, sharply defined borders frame the composition horizontally. The scene is rendered using a flat 2D elevated parallel projection, where all horizontal lines of the train floor, wall edges, and window frames remain strictly horizontal and parallel to the frame edges. The train carriage is drawn using the authentic fukinuki yatai technique, with its roof and ceiling completely omitted to reveal the interior from an elevated view, while both the front long wall in the foreground and the rear long wall in the background remain intact with their sliding doors and glass windows. Inside the roofless carriage, crowded modern Japanese commuters—salarymen in dark suits, students, and passengers holding smartphones—sit side-by-side on long bench seats or stand in the central aisle holding overhead hanging straps. All figures are drawn in the traditional hikime kagihana style with delicate ink lines for eyes and small hooks for noses, framed by sharp contour lines and flat color fills. Along the lower third, the front wall shows silver train doors and lower panels, while the rear wall displays a sequence of rectangular windows set against a plain pale sky. The lighting is completely flat and shadowless throughout the frame, accentuating the precise black line art and opaque pigment blocks. The overall composition is balanced, graphic, and highly stylized, seamlessly blending modern commuting culture with the iconic architectural conventions of Heian handscroll painting.


生成に38分もかかりました。まあ古いGPUなのでエラーにならずに走り切っただけ十分です。
下図保持能力はNanoBanana 2/Proと同じぐらいです。しかし、それでも屋根をぶち抜いた構造を理解できないらしいです...。
NanoBanana系と違い、壁が破壊されることはありませんが、どこが車内、どこからが車外なのかが理解できていないみたいです…。2枚目の画像は結構惜しいですが、でも問題はあります。流石に下図を渡したら一点透視図法への固着は直りました(これですら治らないGPT Image 2よりマシだな)
おまけ:GPT Image 2.5
Xで投稿しましたが、GPT Image 2.5が使えるというメルマガを受け取ったので試してみました。
GPT Image 2.5が使えるようになったってメルマガが来たから試してみた。ただこれが本当に2.5なのかは依然としてわからず…
— chakkun1121 @AI絵巻物プロジェクト (@chakkun1121) September 21, 2026
今までと違って方向が逆とかそういった小さな問題は無くなってきたな pic.twitter.com/qj9ihpwlTY

今まで一発でダメなところを叩いていましたが、今回はむずいぞ。進行方向は悪くないし...。
と思ったらこれ描き込み密度高すぎない?中国の作品とか長恨歌絵巻とかじゃないんだから...。あとよくみると左側の建物の構造が壊れています。
また、色ですが、これ紙でも絹でもない感じです。まさか麻とかじゃないよね?(絵因果経じゃないんだから)
下図を渡した上で通勤電車の様子を生成させてみました。


GPT Image 2.5と思われるモデルに下図を入れて生成させたら今までと大きく違った結果になったぞ
— chakkun1121 @AI絵巻物プロジェクト (@chakkun1121) September 21, 2026
てことはこれもしかして2.5?
ただ吹抜屋台すら現状のどの商用AIでも無理なのかな?
こりゃあ困ったぞ pic.twitter.com/rDUTwWyzer
今までより線画の保持能力は上がっているが、屋根をぶち抜いたというのが理解できなかったのかな?
最後に
結局Qwen Image 2.1ですら絵巻物に対しては敗北してしまいました。やはり絵巻物難しいんですね...。
となるとやはりモデルの自作が必要なのかもな…。この先頑張らないと…。
私は絵巻物を理解して生成できるAIを作ることを目標にAI絵巻物プロジェクトを進めています。しかし、私はまだ大学1年生で個人で進めています。そのため、資金的な問題が多発しています。直近ではこのせいで寝れなくなってきています...。
このプロジェクトを今後も継続するために少しでもいいのでご支援をいただけるとありがたいです。よろしくお願いたします。