メインコンテンツへスキップ

【A brief impression 】The Rings of Power S3 Ep1-4

    Hello Guys.
    I’m Sakanov and welcome to my page.
    I’d like to share a few brief thoughts on the newest episodes 1-4 of The Rings of Power.


    SPOILER ALERT ⚠️
    THIS ARTICLE CONTAINS SPOILERS.


    Ugh… I wasn’t one of those toxic fans out there. I was trying to hold off on making a judgment until the series is over.

    Now Is it time to cast it into the fire? 🔥⛰️

    I honestly don’t even remember exactly what happened in the previous seasons, and I’ve probably forgotten some of the details. But then again, the latest season doesn’t really require you to remember any of it. They keep rushing into new plotlines that completely undermine the character development that came before (which was already insufficient to begin with), while repeating the same things over and over.

    I definitely got the impression that the showrunners had decided to change the pacing and take the story in a different direction. After all, those adjustments seem to have rendered almost all of the character development that had been built up over the previous seasons meaningless.

    For example, Theo somehow ends up becoming one of the Nazgnagôl.

    I know some people had suspected that he might eventually become the Witch-king of Angmar. Okay, I get that he had grown increasingly frustrated with the Elves and the Númenóreans who were colonizing his homeland. But then, all of a sudden, he finds out there’s an opening for a Nazgûl, and apparently decides to apply for the job.

    I feel like this is on us. We let this kid become evil because we expected him to, even though he could have become anyone. I could get behind the idea of him becoming a servant of Sauron, but only if there had been more to justify that transformation. In the previous seasons, he was just a confused kid. His beloved mother was killed, and he was betrayed by other humans. Why would he follow the person who ultimately caused his mother's death?
    His character arc was one of the most interesting parts of the show, but at this point, I have to say it was all too rushed. This was one of the few character arcs that deserved more time to develop.

    And then there’s Gandalf, who suddenly gets all his iconic gear without having to overcome any real challenges. We might get to see how he earns it later, but so far, that part of his journey hasn’t been shown. Please don’t tell me that one word from Tom Bombadil was all it took.

    Meanwhile in Khazad-dûm.

    The story of the House of Durin was actually my favorite part of the show in the previous seasons. They clearly have enough money to bring the glory days of Moria to life, and the music really fits the world of Middle-earth.

    Then there’s Disa, Durin’s wife, apparently cheating on him with her husband’s brother. Why? Was that really necessary?

    I was excited to see his brother potentially take this storyline in a Game of Thrones-like direction, but that was ruined by drama straight out of a reality show.

    Scenes and lines like these suddenly kill my vibe just when the story starts to grab my attention, which Peter Jackson trilogy never did to me.

    Politics in Numenor

    Also, Eärien’s death was tragic, but it felt like the writers simply didn’t know what else to do with her character. She had to hide her identity and eventually sacrificed herself for her family.

    It was certainly a heartbreaking moment, but I honestly can’t remember the show doing enough to establish her characterization and her political stance.

    We finally got to see Anárion, Isildur’s brother.
    I’m looking forward to seeing his journey to Gondor.

    Galadriel’s Romance

    As far as the romantic subplot goes, I honestly couldn’t care less about the whole Celeborn AKA Vecna -Galadriel situation.

    Didn’t Elrond kiss Galadriel before the battle just to pass her an item that would help her escape from the Orc prison? And now her husband is back, despite the romantic tension they’ve already established between her and Sauron. So what are they going to do with that? It’s going to be an awkward mess.


    Following PJs path is not the way

    I’m just amazed by how Peter Jackson managed to fit its lore into just 12 hours (LotR) while TV shows seem unable to do the same even with much more time at their disposal. Perhaps having too much time makes them lose sight of what actually matters in storytelling.

    I’m pretty sure the showrunners heard our criticism, and it seems that inspired them to borrow a little from Peter Jackson’s films, with things like the road trip with an Orc, the Eagles and Nazgnagôl, but that’s just an easy way out of the mess they’ve created in the last few seasons. Rather than fixing the underlying problems, they seem to be relying on nostalgic callbacks.

    The truth is, every single line, choreography and music carry weight in his films, and I just don’t get that feeling from The Rings of Power.

    On the other hand, one of the good things about the show is Charlie Vickers’ performance as Sauron. I didn’t like Sauron in the previous season because he acted too much like an ordinary human being. But now, he has convinced me that everything he has done was part of his plan. He’s capable of taking on any form, and he’s gradually revealing the lack of humanity behind the human facade he had been putting on. I can’t help rooting for him, even though we all know how his story ends…

    Well, I still have more to say, so I’ll come back after the season ends. I started to think the show is just an another fan made and this is multiverse because It makes it easier for me to accept, but I’ll keep my eye on this show anyway, just as the eye watches over Gondor or perhaps I should simply turn a blind eye to its flaws...


     
     
    サカノフです なんでもにわかナードが語りたいことを広く浅い知識でゆるく綴ります てきとうすぎにご注意ください

    あなたへのおすすめ