
AIã®ããã©ãã¯ããã¯ã¹ããè«çã§è§£ãæãã
ãAIãåºããçãã«ãã©ãããŠãããªãã®ïŒããšæã£ãããšã¯ãããŸãããïŒãã£ãŒãã©ãŒãã³ã°ãªã©ã®åŒ·åãªAIã¢ãã«ã¯é«ã粟床ãèªããŸããããã®å€æããã»ã¹ã¯ãã°ãã°ããã©ãã¯ããã¯ã¹ããšåŒã°ããå éšã§äœãèµ·ããŠããã®ãåãããªãããšãå€ãã§ãã
ãæ¬çš¿ã§ã¯ããã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®ãã©ãã¯ããã¯ã¹åé¡ã«æãææ°ã®ç ç©¶ãã玹ä»ããŸããAIã®å€ææ ¹æ ãè«çã§æããã«ããææ³ãæ¯èŒæ€èšŒããå¹ççã«èª¬æãåŒãåºãæ°ããªã¢ãããŒãã®æè¡çèæ¯ãšæçŸ©ããããŠç€ŸäŒã«äžããã€ã³ãã¯ãã«ã€ããŠè§£èª¬ããŸãã
Spotifyã§ããããããé³å£°é ä¿¡ïŒããã¿ã®AIããã¯ã©ãžãªã
ãäžççµæžãã©ãŒã©ã ã®èª¿æ»ã§ã¯ã2030幎ã«å¿
èŠãªã¹ãã«ãã®ç¬¬5äœã«ã奜å¥å¿ãšç涯åŠç¿ããã©ã³ã¯ã€ã³ã奜å¥å¿ã¯è¶£å³ã§ã¯ãªãçµæžçå¿
é ã¹ãã«ã
æèãAIæä»£ã®æåŒ·ã¹ãã«ã奜å¥å¿åããã§è©³èª¬ããŠããŸãã
ãŸããã
ãç§ãã¡ã®çæŽ»ã«æµžéããAIã¯ãå»ç蚺æãéèååŒã®æææ±ºå®ãªã©ãéèŠãªå Žé¢ã§ã掻çšããå§ããŠããŸãããããªäžããAIãã©ãããŠãã®å€æãäžããã®ããã人éãçè§£ã§ããããã«ããããšãExplainable AI (XAI) ãžã®é¢å¿ãæ¥éã«é«ãŸã£ãŠããŸãã
ãåŸæ¥ãAIã®å€æçç±ã説æããããã«æ§ã ãªææ³ãææ¡ãããŠããŸãããããããã®å€ãã¯ååãªä¿¡é Œæ§ãå³å¯ããæ¬ ããŠããŸãããäŸãã°ãLIMEãANCHORãšãã£ããã¥ãŒãªã¹ãã£ãã¯ïŒçµéšåçïŒãªæ¹æ³ã¯ãã¢ãã«ã®æåãããçšåºŠçŽæçã«ç€ºããŠããããã®ã®ã説æã®æ£ç¢ºæ§ïŒåžžã«æãç«ã€ä¿èšŒïŒãæå°éæ§ïŒç¡é§ãªæ å ±ããªãããšïŒã«ã€ããŠã®ç¢ºåºãšããä¿èšŒã¯ãããŸããã§ããã
ãæ¬çš¿ã§åãäžããã®ã¯ããã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®å€æã«å¯ŸããŠè«çã«åºã¥ã説æãäžããç ç©¶ã§ããè«ççãªææ³ã䜿ãã°ã説æã®æ£ãããæ°åŠçã«ä¿èšŒã§ããå¯èœæ§ããããŸããã€ãŸããããã®èª¬æã©ããã®æ¡ä»¶ãæºããå ¥åãªãå¿ ãåãçµæã«ãªãããšããã墚ä»ãã®èª¬æãåŸãããšãã§ããã®ã§ãã
ãããããããããå³å¯ãã远æ±ãããšå¥ã®åé¡ãæµ®äžããŸããè«çããŒã¹ã®èª¬ææ¹æ³ã¯èšç®ã³ã¹ããé«ãããã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®èŠæš¡ã倧ãããªããšå®çšäžæ±ãã«ãããªãããšããã¹ã±ãŒã©ããªãã£ïŒèп𡿡倧ãžã®å¯Ÿå¿ïŒã®èª²é¡ã§ãã
ãä»å玹ä»ããç ç©¶ãè«çã«åºã¥ã説æå¯èœæ§ã®ããã®ãã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã¯ãŒã¯ç¬Šå·åã®æ¯èŒãã¯ããã®ã¹ã±ãŒã©ããªãã£åé¡ãç·©åããããšãã詊ã¿ã§ãã
ãå ·äœçã«ã¯ããã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã®æåãè«çå¶çŽïŒæ°åŒãè«çåŒïŒã«ãšã³ã³ãŒãïŒç¬Šå·åïŒããæ¹æ³ã2çš®é¡æ¯èŒããã©ã¡ããå¹çãã説æãèšç®ã§ããããè©äŸ¡ããŠããŸãã
ãäžã€ã¯æ¢åç ç©¶ã§èª¬æçæã«äœ¿ãããŠããææ³ãããäžã€ã¯å ã æµå¯ŸçäºäŸïŒæå³çã«èª€åé¡ãããå ¥åïŒãæ¢ãç®çã§èæ¡ãããææ³ã説æçšã«å¿çšãããã®ã§ãã
ãåŸè ã®ææ³ã¯å€æ°ãå¶çŽã®æ°ãåæžã§ããããšãç¹åŸŽã§ãããã«ããé«éåãæåŸ ãããŠããŸããç ç©¶ããŒã ã¯äž¡ææ³ã®æ§èœãæ¯èŒå®éšãã説æãèšç®ããæéãã®ãã®ã¯ã»ãŒåçã§ããäžæ¹ãã¢ãã«ãè«çåŒã«å€æããéçšã§ã¯æ°ããææ³ã®æ¹ãæå€§18%é«éã§ãå šäœãšããŠæå€§16%ã®æéççž®ã«ã€ãªããããšãæããã«ããŸããã
ãæ¬çš¿ã§ã¯ããã®ç ç©¶ã®èæ¯ãšã¢ãããŒããäž»èŠãªæè¡ãçµæã®è©³çްãæçŸ©ã«ã€ããŠè§£èª¬ããŸãã
é«ãŸã瀟äŒçèŠè«
ãAIã®èœåãåäžãããã®å¿çšç¯å²ãåºããã»ã©ããã®å€æããããã圱é¿ã¯ç倧ã«ãªããŸããè«æãææããããã«ãç¹ã«ãéèŠãªã·ã¹ãã ãããŒã¿ä¿è·æ³ãæµå¯Ÿçãµã³ãã«ãžã®å¯ŸåŠããšãã£ãæèã«ãããŠã説æå¯èœæ§ã¯æ¥µããŠéèŠã§ã ã Â
ã第äžã«ããéèŠãªã·ã¹ãã ãã§ã®å©çšãæããããŸããäŸãã°ãå»çåéã§AIãã¬ã³ãã²ã³ç»åããçŸæ£ã®å åãæ€åºããå Žåãå»åž«ã¯AIã®èšºæçµæãéµåã¿ã«ããããã«ã¯ãããŸããã
ãAIãç»åã®ã©ã®éšåã«çç®ããã©ã®ãããªç¹åŸŽãæ ¹æ ã«ãéœæ§ããšå€æããã®ããçè§£ã§ããªããã°ãæçµçãªèšºæè²¬ä»»ãè² ãããšã¯ã§ããŸãããåæ§ã«ãéèåéã«ãããèè³å¯©æ»ãèªåååŒã·ã¹ãã ã«ãããŠããAIã®å€ææ ¹æ ãäžéæã§ããã°ãäºæãã¬çµæžçæå€±ãå·®å¥çãªå€æãçããªã¹ã¯ã管çããããšãå°é£ã«ãªããŸã ã Â
ã第äºã«ããããŒã¿ä¿è·æ³ããšããæ³çãªèŠè«ã§ããEUã®äžè¬ããŒã¿ä¿è·èŠåïŒGDPRïŒã«ä»£è¡šãããããã«ãçŸä»£ã®ãã©ã€ãã·ãŒæ³èŠã¯ãå人ã«åœ±é¿ãäžããèªååãããæ±ºå®ã«å¯ŸããŠããã®ããžãã¯ã«é¢ããæå³ã®ããæ å ±ãåŸãæš©å©ãããªãã¡ã説æãåããæš©å©ããä¿éããæ¹åã«åãã£ãŠããŸããããã¯ãXAIãåãªãæè¡çãªéžæè¢ã§ã¯ãªããæ³çãªã³ã³ãã©ã€ã¢ã³ã¹ãéµå®ããããã®å¿ é èŠä»¶ã«ãªãåŸãããšã瀺åããŠããŸã ã Â
ããã®ããã«ãAIã«å¯Ÿãã説æè²¬ä»»ã®èŠè«ã¯ãæè¡ãå®å šãã€å ¬æ£ã«ç€ŸäŒå®è£ ããããã®åºç€ã§ããããã®éèŠæ§ã¯æ¥å¢ãã«é«ãŸã£ãŠããŸãããã®ç ç©¶ãåãçµã課é¡ã¯ãããããçŸå®äžçã®å«ç·ã®èŠè«ã«çŽæ¥å¿ããããšãããã®ã§ããããã®æçŸ©ã¯åŠè¡çãªæ¢æ±ã«çãŸããŸããã
AIãéšããæµå¯Ÿçãµã³ãã«ããšããè åš
ãAIã®ä¿¡é Œæ§ãæºãããããäžã€ã®æ·±å»ãªåé¡ãããæµå¯Ÿçãµã³ãã«ãã®ååšã§ããããã¯ãAIã¢ãã«ãæå³çã«èª€äœåãããããã«å·§åŠã«äœãããå ¥åããŒã¿ã®ããšã§ããè«æã§ã¯ããæ©æ¢°åŠç¿ã¢ãã«ã«ãã£ãŠèª€åé¡ããããã€æ£ããåé¡ãããå¥ã®ã€ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ã¹ãšãããã«ç°ãªãã€ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ã¹ããšå®çŸ©ãããŠããŸã ã Â
ããã®æŠå¿µãçè§£ããããã«ãæåãªäŸãæããŠã¿ãŸããããããç»åèªèAIãããã³ãã®ç»åã99%ã®ç¢ºä¿¡åºŠã§æ£ããããã³ãããšèªèãããšããŸããããã§ã人éã®ç®ã«ã¯ã»ãšãã©æç¥ã§ããªãã»ã©ã®åŸ®å°ãªãã€ãºïŒæåïŒããã®ç»åã«å ããŸãã
ã倿ŽåŸã®ç»åãã人éã®ç®ã«ã¯äŸç¶ãšããŠå šãåããã³ãã«ããèŠããŸããããããããã®ç»åãåãAIã«å ¥åãããšãä»åºŠã¯ãããã¬ã¶ã«ããšããŠé«ã確信床ã§èª€èªèããŠããŸãããšãã£ãçŸè±¡ãèµ·ããåŸãŸã ã Â
ãããã¯åãªãå¶çºçãªãšã©ãŒã§ã¯ãªããAIã®å€æåºæºã®è匱æ§ãçªããæå³çãªãæ»æãã«ãã£ãŠåŒãèµ·ããããšãå¯èœã§ããããèªåé転è»ããæµå¯Ÿçãµã³ãã«ã«ãã£ãŠå å·¥ããããæ¢ãŸããã®æšèããé床å¶éè§£é€ããšèª€èªèããŠããŸã£ããããã®çµæã¯æ²æšãªãã®ã«ãªãã§ããã ã Â
ããã®è åšã«å¯ŸããŠãXAIã¯éèŠãªé²åŸ¡çãšãªãåŸãŸããAIããªãç¹å®ã®å€æãäžããã®ãããã®æ ¹æ ãšãªãç¹åŸŽãæ£ç¢ºã«çè§£ããããšãã§ããã°ãã¢ãã«ã人éãšã¯å šãç°ãªããè匱ãªç¹åŸŽã«äŸåããŠããããšãçºèŠã§ããŸãã
ããã®è匱æ§ãç¹å®ããä¿®æ£ããããšã§ãæµå¯Ÿçãµã³ãã«ã«å¯Ÿããèæ§ïŒé 奿§ïŒãé«ããããšãå¯èœã«ãªãã®ã§ããAIã®å€æããã»ã¹ãçè§£ããããšã¯ãAIãå€éšã®æ¬ºçããå®ãããã®ç¬¬äžæ©ãšèšããŸãã
ãã©ãã¯ããã¯ã¹AIãšè«çã«ãã説æå¯èœæ§
ãã©ãã¯ããã¯ã¹ãšããŠã®ãã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã¯ãŒã¯
ããã£ãŒãã©ãŒãã³ã°ã«ä»£è¡šããã人工ãã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã¯ãŒã¯ïŒANNïŒã¯ãå€å±€ã®ããã¥ãŒãã³ããšåŒã°ããèšç®åäœã§æ§æãããç»åèªèãé³å£°èªèãªã©æ§ã ãªåéã§é«ãæ§èœãçºæ®ããŠããŸãã
ãããããå éšã®éã¿ãèšç®ã®çµã¿åãããéåžžã«è€éãªããã人éãããªããã®åºåã«ãªã£ãã®ãããçŽæçã«çè§£ããã®ãé£ãããšããæ¬ ç¹ããããŸãããããä¿ã«èšããã©ãã¯ããã¯ã¹åé¡ã§ãã
ã説æå¯èœAIïŒXAIïŒã®ç®çã¯ãAIã¢ãã«ã®å éšåŠçãæææ±ºå®ã®çç±ã人éãçè§£ã§ããåœ¢ã§æç€ºããããšã«ãããŸããå ·äœçãªã¢ãããŒããšããŠã¯ã倧ãã2çš®é¡ã«åããããŸãã
ãã²ãšã€ã¯ãã¥ãŒãªã¹ãã£ãã¯ãªææ³ã§ãã¢ãã«ã®åšèŸºã§å ¥åãå°ãå€ããŠã¿ãŠçµæã®å€åã芳å¯ããããšã§ãã©ã®ç¹åŸŽïŒå ¥åèŠçŽ ïŒãéèŠããæšæž¬ãããã®ã§ããåè¿°ã®LIMEïŒã©ã€ã ïŒãANCHORïŒã¢ã³ã«ãŒïŒããã®ä»£è¡šäŸã§ãã
ãLIMEã¯å ¥åããŒã¿åšèŸºã®ã©ã³ãã ãªæåã«å¯Ÿããã¢ãã«ã®å¿çãç·åœ¢ã¢ãã«ã§è¿äŒŒããããã®å ¥åã®ãã®éšåãçµæã«å¹ããŠãããããããšãã£ã説æãäžããŸãããŸãANCHORã¯if-then圢åŒã®ã«ãŒã«ãåŠç¿ããŠãããã®æ¡ä»¶ãæãç«ã€éãåºåã¯å€ãããªãããšãã説æã詊ã¿ãŸãã
ããããããããã®æ¹æ³ã§åŸããã説æã¯ãããŸã§çµéšçã»ç¢ºççãªãã®ã«éããŸããããåžžã«ãããªãããšä¿èšŒãããŠããããã§ã¯ãªãã説æãåé·ã§æ¬è³ªçã§ãªãç¹åŸŽãå«ãå ŽåãããåŸãŸãã
ãããäžã€ã®ã¢ãããŒããæ¬çš¿ã®äž»é¡ã§ããè«çããŒã¹ã®ææ³ã§ãããã¡ãã¯æ°åŠçã»è«çåŠçææ³ãçšããŠAIã¢ãã«ã®åäœãã®ãã®ãè§£æãã確å®ã«æ£ãã説æïŒä¿èšŒä»ãã®èª¬æïŒãèŠã€ããããšãç®æããŸãã
ãå ·äœçã«ã¯ãã¢ãã«ãè«çåŒã§è¡šçŸããããã®è«çåŒãæãç«ã€ãšãã¢ãã«ã®åºåã¯å¿ ãç¹å®ã®ã¯ã©ã¹ã«ãªãããšãã説æãèšç®ããŸãããã®èª¬æã¯å ¥åã®äžéšã®ç¹åŸŽïŒå€æ°ïŒã«çç®ããæ¡ä»¶ãšããŠè¡šããã説æã«å«ãŸããç¹åŸŽããã®ç¹å®ã®å€ã«åºå®ããã°ãä»ã®ç¹åŸŽãã©ãã§ãã£ãŠãã¢ãã«ã®äºæž¬çµæãå€ãããªãããšãããã®ã§ãã
ãããã«ããã®èª¬æãæå°ã§ããããšãã€ãŸãäžèŠãªç¹åŸŽãå«ãŸãªãããšãéèŠãããŸããæå°ã§ãªã説æã ãšèªã¿æã«ãšã£ãŠåé·ã§åããã¥ãããªããããã§ããã ãã³ã³ãã¯ããªèª¬æãæãŸããã®ã§ãã
ãè«çããŒã¹ã®èª¬æã®å©ç¹ã¯ã説æã®æ£ãããè«ççã«ä¿èšŒã§ããç¹ã«ãããŸãã説æãå°ãæ¡ä»¶äžã§ä»ã®äŸå€çãªæåãååšããªãããšã蚌æããããšã§ã説æã®ä¿¡é Œæ§ã確ä¿ããŸãããããæ¬ ç¹ããããŸãããã®èšç®ã«ã¯é«åºŠãªè«çæšè«ãçµåãæé©åã®æè¡ãå¿ èŠã§ãã¢ãã«ãå€§èŠæš¡ã«ãªããšæ¥æ¿ã«èšç®ãé£ãããªãã®ã§ãã
ãå žåçã«ã¯NPå®å šåé¡ãšåŒã°ããéåžžã«å°é£ãªèšç®åé¡ãè§£ãå¿ èŠããããå Žåã«ãã£ãŠã¯èšç®ã«èšå€§ãªæéããããããšããã¹ã±ãŒã©ããªãã£äžã®èª²é¡ããããŸãããããã£ãŠãè«ççã«å³å¯ãªèª¬æãåŸãææ³ã®æ¹è¯ãå¹çåã¯ãXAIç ç©¶ã®éèŠãªããŒããšãªã£ãŠããŸãã
è«çå¶çŽãšMILPãœã«ããŒã«ããã¢ãããŒã
ããã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®èª¬æãè«ççã«æ±ããããã«ã¯ããŸãã¢ãã«èªäœãè«çã®äžçã«ååïŒãšã³ã³ãŒãïŒããå¿ èŠããããŸããããã¯ããã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã®åå±€ã»åãã¥ãŒãã³ã®èšç®ãæ°ççãªå¶çŽåŒã§è¡šçŸããäœæ¥ã§ãã
ãå žåçãªææ³ã§ã¯ããã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã®æ§é ãç·åœ¢æ¹çšåŒãäžçåŒãå Žåã«ãã£ãŠã¯è«çã®å«æïŒif-thenã«ãŒã«ïŒãçšããå¶çŽãšããŠå®åŒåããŸããããããæ°çã¢ãã«ãçµã¿ç«ãŠãäžã§ãMILPïŒæ··åæŽæ°ç·åœ¢èšç»ïŒãœã«ããŒãSATãœã«ããŒãšãã£ãæ±çšã®è§£æ³ãšã³ãžã³ã䜿ããã説æã«è©²åœããæ¡ä»¶äžã§ççŸããªããïŒå¥ã®åºåã«ãªãã±ãŒã¹ããªããïŒãããã§ãã¯ããŸãã
ãMILPãœã«ããŒãšã¯ãããç®çãæå°åã»æå€§åãã€ã€äžé£ã®ç·åœ¢å¶çŽãæºãã倿°ã®å€ãèŠã€ããã¢ã«ãŽãªãºã ã§ããããã§ã¯ç®ç颿°ã¯äž»ã«æ¢çŽ¢ã®ããã®è£å©ã§ãå¶çŽãæºããè§£ïŒèª¬ææ¡ä»¶ãæºãããåºåãç°ãªãäŸïŒãååšãããã©ããã調ã¹ããããã°å è¶³å¯èœæ§åé¡ãšããŠäœ¿çšãããŸãã
ãè§£ãèŠã€ãããªããã°ããã®æ¡ä»¶äžã§åºåãå€ããäŸã¯ååšããªãããããªãã¡èª¬æãæ£ãããšä¿èšŒãããŸãããã®ããã«è«çãšæé©åæè¡ãé§äœ¿ããŠèª¬æãåŸãã®ãè«çããŒã¹XAIã®ã¢ãããŒãã§ãã
ãã§ã¯ãå ·äœçã«ãã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã¯ãŒã¯ãã©ã®ããã«è«çå¶çŽã§è¡šçŸããã®ã§ãããããããŒãã€ã³ãã¯ããã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã®ãã¥ãŒãã³ã®æ¯ãèããè¡šãæ¹æ³ã§ããç¹ã«è¿å¹Žã®ãã£ãŒãã©ãŒãã³ã°ã§ã¯ã掻æ§å颿°ãšããŠReLUãåºã䜿ãããŠããŸãã
ãReLUã¯ãå ¥åã0以äžãªããã®ãŸãŸåºåããè² ãªãåºå0ã«ããããšãã颿°ã§ãã°ã©ãã«æããšæãç·ç¶ã«ãªãããç·åœ¢å¶çŽã§è¡šçŸå¯èœã§ãããããã0ãå ¥åå€ãããšããéç·åœ¢ãªåãæ¿ãéšåãæ±ãããã«ããã°ãã°è£å©å€æ°ãè«ç倿°ãå¿ èŠã«ãªããŸãã
ãäŸãã°ä»¥åã®ä»£è¡šçææ³ã§ã¯ãåReLUãã¥ãŒãã³ã«å¯ŸããŠãã€ããªå€æ°ïŒ0ãŸãã¯1ã®å€ããšã倿°ïŒãå°å ¥ãããã®å€ã1ãªãããã¥ãŒãã³ã¯ã¢ã¯ãã£ãïŒåºå=å ¥åå€ïŒãã0ãªãããã¥ãŒãã³ã¯éã¢ã¯ãã£ãïŒåºå=0ïŒããšããé¢ä¿ã嫿ïŒif-thenïŒã§å¶çŽã«å ããŠããŸããã
ããã®æ¹æ³ã¯è«ççã«ã¯åãããããã®ã§ããããã¥ãŒãã³ã®æ°ã ãäœåã«å€æ°ãå¢ããå¶çŽãå¢ããŠããŸããããå€§èŠæš¡ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã§ã¯ãœã«ããŒã®è² æ ã倧ãããªããŸãã
ã代ããã«ãè«ç嫿ã䜿ããããã°Mæ³ãšåŒã°ããç·åœ¢äžçåŒã®ã¿ã§ReLUã®æ¡ä»¶ã衚ã工倫ãèããããŸãããããã¯ãããåºåã0ã«ãªã£ãŠãããªãå ¥åã¯è² ã«éããªãããšãã£ãé¢ä¿ãã倧ããªä»®æ³ç宿°MïŒäžéå€ïŒã䜿ã£ãäžçåŒã§è¡šçŸãããã¯ããã¯ã§ãã
ããã®æ¹æ³ã ãšè«ç嫿ãæç€ºçã«æžããã«æžã¿ãå¿ èŠãªå€æ°ãè¥å¹²æžãããŸãã2019幎ã«Tjengãã«ãã£ãŠææ¡ãããææ³ã¯ãŸãã«ãã®èãæ¹ã«åºã¥ããŠãããããšããšã¯ãã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã®ããã¹ãæ§æ€èšŒïŒå ¥åã«ãã€ãºãæ»æãå ããŠãåé¡ãå€ãããªããæ€èšŒããåé¡ïŒã®ããã«éçºãããŸããã
ããã®ç ç©¶ã§ã¯Tjengãã®ãšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°ææ³ã説æå¯èœæ§ã®æèã«é©å¿ïŒAdaptationïŒããåŸæ¥ææ³ïŒFischetti & Joã«ãã2018å¹Žã®æ¹åŒãªã©ïŒãšæ¯èŒããŠããŸãã
æ¬ç ç©¶ã®ç®çãšææ¡å 容
ãåç¯ãŸã§ã§ããã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã®èª¬æãè«ççã«æ±ããã«ã¯ã¢ãã«ãå¶çŽã§è¡šçŸããå¿ èŠãããããã®è¡šçŸæ¹æ³ãèšç®å¹çã«å€§ãã圱é¿ããããšã説æããŸããã
ãæ¬ç ç©¶ã®ç®çã¯ãæ¢åã®è«çãšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°ææ³ãšæ°ãã«é©å¿ãããšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°ææ³ã®ã©ã¡ããå¹çãã説æèšç®ãè¡ããããæ¯èŒããè«çããŒã¹XAIã®ã¹ã±ãŒã©ããªãã£æ¹åã«åããç¥èŠãåŸãããšã§ãã
ãç¹ã«æ³šç®ããã®ã¯ã(1) ãã¥ãŒã©ã«ããããå¶çŽã«å€æããã®ã«èŠããæéã(2) å®éã«èª¬æãæ±ããèšç®ïŒMILPãœã«ããŒã«ããæ¢çŽ¢ïŒã«èŠããæéããã㊠(3) ããããåãããããŒã¿ã«ã®åŠçæéãã®3ç¹ã§ãã
ãäž»ãªææ¡å 容ãšããŠãæ¬ç ç©¶ã§ã¯ä»¥äžã®2ã€ã®ãšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°ææ³ãæ¯èŒããŠããŸãã
ææ³AïŒåŸæ¥ææ³ïŒ
ãæ¢åç ç©¶ã§èª¬æçæã«äœ¿çšãããŠãããšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°ãããã¯Fischetti and Jo (2018)ã«ããææ³ãåºã«ãIgnatievã (2019) ãANNã®èª¬æã«å¿çšãããã®ã§ããåãã¥ãŒãã³ã«è£å©å€æ°ãæãããè«ç嫿ãçšããŠReLUã®ON/OFFã衚çŸããã®ãç¹åŸŽã§ããæ¯èŒå¯Ÿè±¡ãšããŠã嫿ããã®ãšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°ããšåŒã¶ããšã«ããŸãã
ææ³BïŒææ¡ææ³ïŒ
ãTjengã (2019) ã®ãšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°ãANNã®èª¬æèšç®ã«å¿çšã»æ¹è¯ãããã®ãè£å©ã®ã¹ã©ãã¯å€æ°ãè«ç嫿ã䜿ãããç·åœ¢äžçåŒã®ã¿ã§ã¢ãã«ã衚çŸããŸãã
ãå ã®Tjengææ³ã§ã¯èª¬æå¯èœæ§ã®ããã®ä»æãïŒããã®ã¯ã©ã¹ä»¥å€ã®åºåãåã€ç¶æ³ã¯ãªãããã調ã¹ãå¶çŽïŒãç¡ãã£ããããæ¬ç ç©¶ã§ã¯ãããè£ã远å ã®å¶çŽãå°å ¥ããŠããŸãããã®ææ³ãã嫿ãªãã®ãšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°ããšåŒã³ãŸãã
ãäž¡ææ³ãšãããã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããå ã®åãã¥ãŒãã³ã«ã€ããŠäžäžçïŒåãåŸãæå°å€ã»æå€§å€ïŒãäºåã«èšç®ããŠå¶çŽã«çµã¿èŸŒã工倫ãããŠããŸãããã¥ãŒãã³ã®äžäžçãšã¯ããã®ãã¥ãŒãã³ã«ããåŸãåºåã®ç¯å²ã§ãããã¯ãããã¯ãŒã¯æ§é ãšå ¥åã®ç¯å²ããèšç®ã§ããŸãã
ãäžäžçãç¥ã£ãŠãããšå è¿°ã®ããã°Mæ³ã§äœ¿ãMã®å€ãåŒãç· ããïŒäžèŠã«å€§ããããªãïŒããšãã§ãããœã«ããŒã®æ¢çŽ¢ç¯å²ãæžãããŠé«éåã«ã€ãªãããŸããäŸãã°ããããã¥ãŒãã³ã®åºåã¯ã©ããªå ¥åã§ã0以äž100以äžããšããããšãåããã°ãMãšããŠ100ã䜿ãã°ååã§ããã以äžã¯ç¡é§ã«ãªããŸããæ¬ç ç©¶ã§ã¯ããã®äžäžçãèšç®ããããã»ã¹ãå«ããŠå¹çè©äŸ¡ãè¡ã£ãŠããŸãã
ããŸãã説æãèšç®ããã¢ã«ãŽãªãºã èªäœã¯Ignatievã(2019)ãææ¡ãã鿬¡æ¶å»æ³ãèžè¥²ããŠããŸããå ·äœçã«ã¯ããŸãå ¥åå šäœãæ¡ä»¶CãšãïŒã€ãŸãããã®å ¥åã®ãã¹ãŠã®ç¹åŸŽïŒäžããããå€ããšããæ¡ä»¶ïŒããããåºåEãè«ç嫿ããïŒCãæãç«ãŠã°åžžã«Eãæãç«ã€ïŒããšã確èªããŸãã
ããããæãç«ã€éããCã¯èª¬æåè£ã«ãªããŸããæ¬¡ã«ããã®ãã¡äžã€ã®ç¹åŸŽãæ¡ä»¶ããåãé€ããC'ã«ã€ããŠãC'ãäŸç¶ãšããŠEã嫿ããããã§ãã¯ããŸããããæãç«ã€ãªããã®ç¹åŸŽã¯èª¬æã«ã¯äžèŠãªã®ã§åé€ããæãç«ããªããã°ãã®ç¹åŸŽã¯èª¬æã«äžå¯æ¬ ãªã®ã§æ®ãããšãã£ãå ·åã«ãç¹åŸŽãäžã€ãã€æ€èšŒããŠãããŸãã
ãæçµçã«æ®ã£ãæ¡ä»¶C_mãæå°èª¬æãšãªããŸãããã®ãã§ãã¯ã«æ¯åãœã«ããŒã䜿ã£ãŠå è¶³äžèœãã©ããïŒC'ãã€ã¢ãã«ãã€ãåºåãEã§ãªãããåæã«æºããããïŒãå€å®ãããããç¹åŸŽã®æ°ã ããœã«ããŒåŒã³åºããçºçããŸãã
ããããã£ãŠãäžåäžåã®ãœã«ããŒå®è¡ãå¹çåããããšãå šäœã®é«éåã«ç¹ãããŸãããšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°ææ³ã®æ¹è¯ã¯ãŸãã«ãã®éšåã§å¹æãçºæ®ããã¯ãã§ãã
å®éšãšçµæ
ãç ç©¶ããŒã ã¯äžè¿°ã®2ææ³ïŒå«æãã vs 嫿ãªãïŒãæ¯èŒããããã倧ãã2ã€ã®å®éšãè¡ããŸããã䜿çšããã®ã¯ããããæ¯èŒçå°èŠæš¡ãªãã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã§ãUCIæ©æ¢°åŠç¿ãªããžããªãªã©ããåŸã12çš®é¡ã®ããŒã¿ã»ãããçšããŠã¢ãã«ãåŠç¿ããŠããŸãã
ãåããŒã¿ã»ããã®ç¹åŸŽéã®æ°ã¯9ïœ32ãããŒã¿æ°ã¯156ïœ691ãšãããŠãããåé¡ã¿ã¹ã¯ïŒ2ã¯ã©ã¹ãŸãã¯å€ã¯ã©ã¹åé¡ïŒã«å¯ŸããŠ2å±€ã®é ãå±€ïŒå20ãã¥ãŒãã³ïŒãæã€ãã¥ãŒã©ã«ããããèšç·ŽãããŸããã
ããŸããã®12ã¢ãã«ã«ã€ããŠãããŒã¿ã»ããå ã®å šã€ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ã¹ããããã«å¯Ÿãã説æãäž¡ææ³ã§èšç®ããå¹³åèšç®æéãæ¯èŒããŠããŸãïŒå®éš1ïŒãããã«ã12åã®ãã¡votingããŒã¿ã»ããïŒ16ç¹åŸŽéãæã€æç¥šããŒã¿ïŒãéžã³ããããã¯ãŒã¯ã®æ§é ãå€åãããå Žåã«äž¡ææ³ã®æ§èœãã©ãå€ãããã詳现ã«èª¿ã¹ãŸããïŒå®éš2ïŒã
ãå ·äœçã«ã¯ã(a) é ãå±€1æã§ãã¥ãŒãã³æ°ã10ãã100ãŸã§å¢ããã±ãŒã¹ã(b) é ãå±€2æã§åå±€ã®ãã¥ãŒãã³æ°ã10ãã40ãŸã§å¢ããã±ãŒã¹ãã®äºéãã詊ãããããã説æèšç®æéãæž¬å®ããŠããŸãã
ããã¹ãŠã®å®éšã§ã説æãèšç®ããã¢ã«ãŽãªãºã ã¯åè¿°ã®é次æ¶å»æ³ã§çµ±äžããã䜿çšãããœã«ããŒã¯IBM CPLEXïŒMILPãœã«ããŒïŒã§ãããŸãããšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°æ§ç¯æã«åãã¥ãŒãã³ã®äžäžçãæ±ããããã®æé©åèšç®ãè¡ãããã®æéããæ§ç¯æéããšããŠæž¬å®ããŠããŸãã
èå¯
ãä»å玹ä»ããç ç©¶ã¯ããã©ãã¯ããã¯ã¹ãšåãããã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã®å éšãè«ççã«è§£æãã人éã«çè§£å¯èœãªèª¬æãæäŸãããšãããã£ã¬ã³ãžã«å¯Ÿããäžæ©åé²ã瀺ãããã®ã§ãã
ãæè¡çæçŸ©ãšããŠã¯ãæ¢åã®è«çããŒã¹èª¬æææ³ã®ããã«ããã¯ã ã£ãèšç®å¹çã®åé¡ã«çç®ãããšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°ã®æ¹è¯ã«ãã£ãŠäžéšè§£æ±ºãå³ã£ãç¹ãæããããŸãã
ãç¹ã«ã倿°ãšå¶çŽã®åæžãšããã¢ã«ãŽãªãºã äžã®å·¥å€«ã§ãçè«çã«ã¯åãçµæïŒæ£ç¢ºãªèª¬æïŒãä¿ã¡ã€ã€å¹çãé«ããããããšã瀺ããã®ã¯æçšã§ããå®éšçµæãããæ°ææ³ã¯ãããã¯ãŒã¯æ§é ãåçŽãªå Žåã«é¡èãªæ§èœåäžã瀺ããè€éã«ãªããšåçæ§èœã«çãŸãããšãåãããŸããã
ãããããæšæž¬ã§ããã®ã¯ããšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°ææ³ã®æ¹è¯ã ãã§ã¯ãããæ·±ããããã¯ãŒã¯ãããå€ãã®ãã¥ãŒãã³ã絡ãå Žåã«ã¯éçããããããããªããšããç¹ã§ããã¹ã±ãŒã©ããªãã£ã®èª²é¡ã¯äžæäžå€ã«ã¯è§£æ±ºããããããªã工倫ãå¿ èŠã§ãããã
ã瀟äŒçã€ã³ãã¯ãã®èгç¹ã§ã¯ããã®ãããªå³å¯ãªèª¬æå¯èœæ§ã®æè¡ãçºå±ããããšã«ãããAIã·ã¹ãã ã®éææ§ãšä¿¡é Œæ§ã倧ããåäžããå¯èœæ§ããããŸããå»çãæ³åéãªã©ã人åœãæš©å©ã«é¢ããé åã§ã¯ãAIã®å€ææ ¹æ ãæ£ããçè§£ã説æã§ããããšãäžå¯æ¬ ã§ãã
ãè«çããŒã¹XAIã¯ãAIã誀ã£ã倿ããããã©ãããã®ãïŒããšããåãã«ãçããããããŸãã説æãæ£ãããã°ãã説æã«åèŽããæ¡ä»¶äžã§ããèª€å€æããããšããå ·äœçãªäºäŸãããšã«ã¢ãã«ãæ¹åããããéã«èª¬æãæ ¹æ ã«ã¢ãã«ã®æ±ºå®ã人éãæ€èšŒãããããããšãã§ããã§ãããã
ããŸããAIã«èª¬æè²¬ä»»ãæãããæè¡ã¯ãä»åŸå¶å®ãããã§ãããAIèŠå¶ãžã®é©åããäŒæ¥ãAIãå°å ¥ããéã®ç€ŸäŒçä¿¡çšã®ç¢ºä¿ã«ãå¯äžããŸãã
ããã£ãšããçŸç¶ã§ã¯è«çããŒã¹ã®èª¬ææè¡ã«ã課é¡ããããŸããæå€§ã®ãã®ã¯ãã¯ãèšç®ã®éãã§ãããæ¬ç ç©¶ã§ãå®éšã®å¯Ÿè±¡ã¯2å±€çšåºŠã®æ¯èŒçå°èŠæš¡ãªãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«éãããŠããŸãã
ãæ·±å±€åŠç¿ã®ãæ·±ããããæ°åå±€ã»æ°çŸäžãã©ã¡ãŒã¿ãšãã£ãå€§èŠæš¡ã¢ãã«ã«çŽæ¥ãã®ææ³ãé©çšããã®ã¯ããŸã é£ãããšèšããããåŸãŸãããç ç©¶ããŒã èªèº«ããä»åŸã¯ããŒã¿ã»ããã®äžéšã ãã䜿ã£ãŠã§ããã倧ããªANNã§è©Šããå±€ããã¥ãŒãã³æ°ãããã«å¢ãããå®éšãå¿ èŠã ãšè¿°ã¹ãŠããŸãã
ãããã«ãä»ã®ãšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°ææ³ãžã®æ¡åŒµã瀺åãããŠããŸããå®éããã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããæ€èšŒã®æèã§ã¯ãSATãœã«ããŒã掻çšããSMTïŒå è¶³å¯èœæ§ã¢ãžã¥ãçè«ïŒãœã«ããŒã«ããææ³ããã¢ãã«ãç°¡ç¥åããåªå®ã»ã¹ã©ã€ã·ã³ã°æè¡ãªã©ã倿§ãªã¢ãããŒããååšããŸãã
ãæ¬ç ç©¶ã¯ããããšçŽæ¥ç«¶åãããã®ã§ã¯ãããŸããããç®çãåããããæè¡çŸ€ãšããŠãäºãã«çºå±ãä¿ãé¢ä¿ã«ãããŸãã
ãç¹ã«ããããã¯ãŒã¯ãåçŽåãããã«ãŒãã³ã°/ã¹ã©ã€ã·ã³ã°ïŒäžèŠãªãã¥ãŒãã³ãéã¿ãåæžããåçæ§èœã®ã¢ãã«ãäœãïŒãšã®çµã¿åããã¯ææã§ããLahav & Katz (2021)ã«ããç ç©¶ã§ã¯ã圢åŒçæ€èšŒãè¡ãååŠçãšããŠãããã¯ãŒã¯ãå°ããããææ³ãææ¡ãããŠããã説æå¯èœæ§ã®èšç®ã§ãåæ§ã®ã¢ã€ãã¢ã䜿ãããããããŸããã
ãã€ãŸãã倧ããªãããã¯ãŒã¯ããæ¬è³ªçãªéšåã ããæœåºããããã«å¯ŸããŠè«çãšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°ãè¡ãã°ãããèŠæš¡ã®å€§ããªåé¡ã«ãé©çšã§ããå¯èœæ§ããããŸããæ¬ç ç©¶ã®æ°ææ³ãšããããã¢ãã«ç°¡ç¥åææ³ãçµã¿åãããã°ãããäžå±€ã®å¹çåãæåŸ ã§ããã§ãããã
ããŸãã説æã®è³ªãšãã芳ç¹ãéèŠã§ããæ¬ç ç©¶ã¯äž»ã«èšç®æ§èœã®æ¯èŒã§ããããè«çããŒã¹ã®èª¬æããŠãŒã¶ã«ãšã£ãŠæ¬åœã«çè§£ããããããæçšããšããè©äŸ¡ãå¿ èŠã§ãã
ã説æãæå°ã§ããããšã¯ã·ã³ãã«ãã«ç¹ãããŸãããäŸãã°ããããç¹åŸŽXãçã§ããããšããåäžæ¡ä»¶ã ãã ã£ãå Žåã人éã«ãšã£ãŠã¯ããªããããæ±ºãæã«ãªãã®ãïŒããšããå¥ã®çåãçãããããããŸããã
ã説æå¯èœAIã®ç©¶æ¥µçãªãŽãŒã«ã¯ã人éãAIã®å€æã«çŽåŸã§ããããã«ããããšã§ãããã®ããã«ã¯ãè«ççãªæ£ããã«å ããŠã人éãšã®çžäºäœçšãçŽèгçãªçè§£ãšãã£ãèŠçŽ ãèæ ®ããŠããå¿ èŠãããã§ãããã
ãŸãšã
ããã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®ããªããã®çµæã«ãªã£ããããè§£ãæããããã«ãè«çã®åãåãããšããã¢ãããŒããæ³šç®ãããŠããŸããæ¬çš¿ã§ã¯ãè«çããŒã¹ã®èª¬æå¯èœæ§ææ³ã«ãããŠéµãšãªãã¢ãã«ã®ãšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°æ¹æ³ã®éãã«çç®ããææ°ç ç©¶ãããšã«2ã€ã®ææ³ã®æ¯èŒçµæã玹ä»ããŸããã
ãåŸæ¥ã¯èª¬æã®å³å¯ããšèšç®å¹çã®äž¡ç«ã課é¡ã§ããããæ°ããªãšã³ã³ãŒãã£ã³ã°ã®å·¥å€«ã«ãã£ãŠäžéšæ¹åãèŠãããç¹ã«ã·ã³ãã«ãªãããã¯ãŒã¯ã§ã¯å¹æçã§ããããšã瀺ãããŸãããããã¯ãAIã®å éšãããéããããã®ã«ããç§ãã¡ãAIãå®å¿ããŠæŽ»çšã§ããæªæ¥ã«åããéèŠãªäžæ©ã§ãã
ããã¡ããã解決ãã¹ã課é¡ã¯ãŸã ãããŸããæ·±ããã¥ãŒã©ã«ããããžã®é©çšãå€§èŠæš¡ããŒã¿ãžã®å¯Ÿå¿ã説æå 容ã®åŠ¥åœæ§ã®è©äŸ¡ãªã©ã説æå¯èœAIã®ç ç©¶ã¯ä»ãªãçºå±éäžã§ãããããçå®ã«åé²ããŠããããšã確ãã§ãã
ããšãã
ãAIãç§ãã¡ã®æ¥åžžã«æº¶ã蟌ã¿ããã®æ©æµã享åããäžæ¹ã§ããã®ãè³¢ããã®æºæ³ãèŠããªãããšãžã®æŒ ç¶ãšããäžå®ãæããããšã¯ãªãã§ãããããæ¬çš¿ã§è§£èª¬ããç ç©¶ã¯ããŸãã«ãã®AIã®ãå¿ã®äžããè«çã®åã§èŠãèŠãããšãã詊ã¿ã®äžã€ã§ãã
ãè€éãªãã¥ãŒã©ã«ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®å€æãã人éãçè§£ã§ãããèšèãïŒãã®å Žåã¯è«çåŒïŒã«ç¿»èš³ãããã®ç¿»èš³äœæ¥ãããã«å¹ççã«è¡ãããšãã課é¡ã«åãçµãã§ããŸãããã®éã®ãã¯ãŸã å§ãŸã£ãã°ããã§ããã倧ããªAIãããè€éãªåé¡ãžã®å¯Ÿå¿ãªã©ãå€ãã®ææŠãæ®ãããŠããŸãã
ãæ¬çš¿ãéããŠåŸãããã¢ã€ãã¢ãç¥èããããªãã«å°ãã§ã圹ç«ã€ããšãé¡ã£ãŠããŸããããããã®èšäºãåèã«ãªã£ããšæããŠããã ããŸãããããã²ããããããããã©ããŒããããŠããã ãããšå±ã¿ã«ãªããŸãããããããææ°ã®AIæ å ±ãå®è·µçãªæŽ»çšãã³ãããå±ãããŸãã®ã§ãåŒãç¶ããèªã¿ããã ãããšå¬ããã§ãã
â ïžãéèŠïŒChatGPTã䜿ãããªãã人ã¯å
šäœã®3å²ä»¥äž
ããªããïŒã質ååãã®å·®ã§ãã
ãå®ã¯ãAIãã10åã®äŸ¡å€ãåŒãåºããåãã®ç«ãŠæ¹ãã«ã¯ç§åŠçãªæ³åããããŸããGoogleã20%ã«ãŒã«ã§å®èšŒããAmazonã®ããŸã¹ãæšå¥šããæ¹æ³ãå
šãŠãAIæä»£ã®æåŒ·ã¹ãã«ã奜å¥å¿åããã§å
¬éäžã
ãAIãç¬æã«ãçãããè¿ãä»ãåè² ã®åããç®ã¯ãåããã«ããããã®ç§å¯ã𿿥ã®ä»äºã§äœ¿ãã13ã®å®è·µããŒã«ãåçž®ããæèãAIæä»£ã®æåŒ·ã¹ãã«ã奜å¥å¿åããããã²ãã§ãã¯ããŠã¿ãŠãã ããã
ãLLMãç»åçæAIã«å ±éãããæ®éçãªå ¥åã®ååããäœç³»çã«è§£èª¬ããã«ã·ããŒã·ã§ã³å¯Ÿçãåºåã®å®å®åãè©äŸ¡ææ³ãç¶²çŸ ããå®åãç ç©¶ã«çŽçµããå®è·µçã¬ã€ãããã¯ã§ããã¢ãã«ã®é²åã«å·Šå³ããã䜿ããæ¹æ³ã身ã«ã€ãããããã³ãããšã³ãžãã¢ã«æé©ã2025幎7æ9æ¥åã484ããŒãžã®å å®ããå 容ãä¿¡é Œã§ããçæAIéçšãç®æããªãããŸãæå ã«çœ®ãããäžåã§ã
ãèè ã®James PhoenixãšMike Taylorã¯ãAIããã³ããã£ã³ã°ã®ç¬¬äžäººè ãšããŠç¥ãããæ°ã ã®äŒæ¥ã§AI掻çšãæåã«å°ããŠããŸãããæ¬æžã§ã¯ã圌ãã®çµéšããå°ãåºããããæ®éçãªå ¥åã®ååãããè±å¯ãªå®äŸãšãšãã«åŠã¶ããšãã§ããŸãã
ãã¢ãã«ãé²åããŠãé³è åããªãæ¬è³ªçãªã¹ãã«ã身ã«ã€ããããªãã®AI掻çšã次ã®ã¬ãã«ãžãšåŒãäžããŸãããšã³ãžãã¢ã¯ãã¡ãããAIãæ¬æ Œçã«äœ¿ãããªãããå šãŠã®æ¹ã«å¿ æºã®äžåã§ãã
ãçæAIæä»£ã®çŸ éç€ãšãªã決å®çãæ±äº¬å€§åŠæŸå°Ÿã»å²©æŸ€ç 究宀ãç·åãçµéããçæAIææ°ååã培åºè§£èª¬ãChatGPTç»å Žä»¥éãæ¥éã«é²åããçæAIæè¡ã®çŸåšå°ãšæªæ¥ããæ¥æ¬ã代衚ããAIç ç©¶è ãã¡ãå æ¬çã«åæããŠããŸãã
ã2025幎3æåè¡ãæè¡ã®æ žå¿ããããžãã¹æŽ»çšãåœå
å€ã®æ³èŠå¶ããããŠå®å
šæ§ã«è³ããŸã§ãä»ç¥ãã¹ãæ
å ±ãç¶²çŸ
çã«è§£èª¬ãAIãšãŒãžã§ã³ãããã«ãã¢ãŒãã«åãšãã£ãææ°ãã¬ã³ããæŒãããŠããŸãã
çæAIããžãã¹ã«é¢ãããã¹ãŠã®æ¹ã«ãšã£ãŠå¿
æºã®äžåãæ¿åããAIæ¥çã§ç¢ºããªå€æãäžãããã«ãä¿¡é Œã§ããæ
å ±æºã§ãã
ãGoogleã®ããã¯ãªãŒããTom Longæ°ãæå±ãããè¯ãã³ãŒã vs æªãã³ãŒããã®å¯Ÿæ¯åœ¢åŒã§åŠã¶å®è·µã¬ã€ãããåãã³ãŒãããããè¯ãã³ãŒãããžãé·æçã«ä¿å®ã»æ¡åŒµå¯èœãªã³ãŒããæžãããã®å®è·µçãªæéãäœç³»åããå¿ èªæžã§ãã
ãåã«åäœããã ãã§ãªããèªã¿ãããããã¹ãããããã倿Žã«åŒ·ãã³ãŒããšã¯äœãïŒæ¬æžã§ã¯ãåœåèŠåã颿°èšèšããšã©ãŒåŠçãæœè±¡åã®ååãªã©ãããã®ãšã³ãžãã¢ãæ¥ã å®è·µããŠãããè¯ãã³ãŒããã®æžãæ¹ããè±å¯ãªå®äŸãšãšãã«è§£èª¬ããŸãã
ãç¹çãã¹ãã¯ãæè¡çãªæ£ããã ãã§ãªããããŒã éçºãã³ãŒãã¬ãã¥ãŒã§ã®èгç¹ãç¶²çŸ ããŠããç¹ãã³ãŒãã®å¯èªæ§ãä¿å®æ§ãæ¡åŒµæ§ãé«ããããšã§ãéçºé床ã®åäžãšãã°ã®åæžãå®çŸã§ããŸããç¶ç¶çãªå質åäžãç®æããšã³ãžãã¢ãéçºãªãŒããŒã«æé©ãªäžåã§ãã