
75幎è¶ããGPT-4.5ãã€ãã«ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ããã¯ãªã¢ïŒ73%ã®äººéãAIã人éãšèª€èª
ãã€ã³ã
GPT-4.5ããæšæºçãªäžè éãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã§73%ã®ç¢ºçã§äººéãšèª€èªãããåããŠåæ Œãšèªå®ããã ã»ç ç©¶ã¯ã«ãªãã©ã«ãã¢å€§åŠãµã³ãã£ãšãŽæ ¡ã宿œããLLaMa-3.1-405Bã¯56%ã§äººéãšèª€èªãããããGPT-4.5ãäžåã£ã
ããŒã¹ã©ã€ã³ã¢ãã«ïŒGPT-4oãELIZAïŒã¯ãããã21%ã23%ãšå€§å¹ ã«äœã誀èªçã«ãšã©ãŸã£ã
ãã«ãœãïŒäººæ ŒïŒããã³ãããçšããå ŽåãAIã®äººéããããå€§å¹ ã«åäžãããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãçªç Žã«å¯äžãã
åå è ã¯è«çåãç¥èãããèšèªã¹ã¿ã€ã«ã察話ã®èªç¶ããªã©ã瀟äŒçã»ææ çãªèŠçŽ ã§å€æããåŸåã匷ãã£ã
AIããç¡ç¥ãè£ ããããšã§äººéãããèŠãããªã©ãå·§åŠãªæš¡å£æŠç¥ãæåã®éµãšãªã£ã
å€ãã®äººãAIãšäººéãåºå¥ã§ãããèå¥ç²ŸåºŠã¯å¹Žéœ¢ãç¥èã¬ãã«ã«å€§ããäŸåããªãã£ã
çæéã®å¯Ÿè©±ã«ãããŠAIã人éãšåºå¥ã§ããªããªã£ãããšã§ã瀟äŒçã»çµæžç圹å²ã«ãããAIã®ä»£æ¿å¯èœæ§ãæµ®äž
ãåœäººïŒãã§ã€ã¯ã»ãã¥ãŒãã³ïŒããšã®çžäºäœçšãå¢ããããšã§ã人éçãªäº€æµã®äŸ¡å€ãæãªãããå±éºæ§ããã
ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã¯ãç¥èœããããã人éãããããæž¬å®ããŠãããçŸä»£ã®AIã¯ãã®åºæºã§äººéã«è¿«ãã€ã€ãã
çšèªè§£èª¬
ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãïŒTuring testïŒïŒæ©æ¢°ïŒäººå·¥ç¥èœïŒã®èœåãã人éã®ãç¥ç掻åããšåçã§ãããããŸãã¯ãããšåºå¥ãã€ããªãçšåºŠãã確ãããããã®ãã¹ã
æ¬æ
äžè ã«ãããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã«ãããŠãã«ãªãã©ã«ãã¢å€§åŠãµã³ãã£ãšãŽæ ¡ã®ç ç©¶è ãã¯çŸåšã®AIã¢ãã«ãè©äŸ¡ããLLMããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã«åæ Œããããšã蚌æããã äœã ãšïŒãAIããŸããæšæºçãªäžè ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã«åæ Œãããšã¯ãããã確åºãã蚌æ ä»ãã§ïŒ ã«ãªãã©ã«ãã¢å€§åŠãµã³ãã£ãšãŽæ ¡ã®ç ç©¶è ãã¯ã4ã€ã®AIã·ã¹ãã ã系統çã«è©äŸ¡ããå€§èŠæš¡èšèªã¢ãã«ïŒLLMïŒããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã«åæ Œããããšã蚌æããã èšãæããã°ãä»åŸããªããšç±å¿ã«ãã£ããããŠãããé¡èŠç¥ãã®ä»äººãã¯ããããããã人éã§ã¯ãªããããããªãã ãã¹ãã§ã¯ã人éãšAIã·ã¹ãã ã®äž¡æ¹ãšåæã«5åéäŒè©±ãè¡ããã©ã¡ãããæ¬ç©ã®äººéããã倿ããã çµæãšããŠãAIã¯ãªããšãæ¬ç©ã®äººéãããã人éãããæ¯ãèã£ãã
GPT-4.5ã¯73%ã®å²åã§äººéãšèªèãããå®éã®äººéã®åå è ãèããäžåã£ãã
LLaMa-3.1-405Bã¯56%ã®èå¥çãç²åŸãã人éãšææå·®ã¯ãªãã£ãã
ããŒã¹ã©ã€ã³ã¢ãã«ïŒELIZAãšGPT-4oïŒã®æåçã¯ãã©ã³ãã ãªç¢ºçãèããäžåã£ãïŒãããã23%ãš21%ïŒã
人é¡ã¯ã人éãããè¡åãæš¡å£ãããç«¶äºã§è² ããã®ã ïŒ

æ°ããªç ç©¶ã¯ãLLMã®ç¥èœã®æ¬è³ªã«æ·±ã圱é¿ãäžããã§ãããã ããã ãã§ãªããAIã瀟äŒçµæžã®åŽé¢ã«ã©ã®ãããªåœ±é¿ãäžããããäºæž¬ããã®ã«åœ¹ç«ã¡ãéåžžã«åèã«ãªãã

人工ç¥èœã®å é§è ã§ãããèšç®æ©ç§åŠè ã§ããããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ã¯ããããããèèã®é°ã§åãã§ãããã§ããããAIã¯ã€ãã«åœŒã倢èŠãé«ããŸã§çºå±ããã®ã ã

ããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãïŒæ©æ¢°ã¯äººãéšããã®ãïŒã
75幎åãã¢ã©ã³ã»ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ã¯æ©æ¢°ãç¥èœãåããŠãããã©ãããå€å®ããæ¹æ³ãšããŠãæš¡å£ã²ãŒã ããæå±ããã

AIã®çºå±ã«äŒŽãããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã¯åºãç¥ãããããã«ãªã£ãã ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã§ã¯ããã¹ãæ åœè ã¯ããã¹ããã£ããã€ã³ã¿ãŒãã§ãŒã¹ãéããŠãåæã«2ã€ã®ããã£ããããéå§ããã1ã€ã¯äººéããã1ã€ã¯AIã§ããã AIãšäººéã¯ã©ã¡ããå¿ æ»ã«ãã¹ãæ åœè ã«ãèªåãããæ£çæ£éã®äººéã§ãããçžæãAIããããã§ãããšèšŒæããããšããã

ãããã¹ãæ åœè ãã©ã¡ãã人éããæ£ç¢ºã«èªèã§ããªãå Žåãããã¯æ©æ¢°ããã¹ãã«åæ Œããããšãæå³ããã ããã¯ãAIã人éã®æèãšè¡šçŸæ¹æ³ãæš¡å£ã§ããããšãæå³ããã
ã»75幎ããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ã»ãã¹ãã®æ»ç¥
éå»75幎éãå€ãã®äººã ããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ã»ãã¹ãã«åæ Œå¯èœãªã·ã¹ãã éçºã詊ã¿ãŠããããæåã«ã¯è³ããªãã£ãããã®åŸãLLMïŒå€§èŠæš¡èšèªã¢ãã«ïŒãç»å Žãããåæ£çµ±èšãšåŒ·ååŠç¿ãã£ãŒãããã¯ã掻çšããããšã§ãLLMã¯èšèªçæãåŠç¿ããåã³ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ã»ãã¹ãã«æ³šç®ãéãŸãããã«ãªã£ãã
æè¿ãäºè éãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ã»ãã¹ããç°¡ç¥åãããã®ãçšããŠLLMã®è©äŸ¡ãè¡ãç ç©¶ãäºä»¶çºè¡šãããããã¹ãã§ã¯ã質åè ãæ©æ¢°ãŸãã¯ä»ã®åå è ãšãã£ãããè¡ããçžæã人éã§ãããã倿ãããããç ç©¶ã§ã¯ãGPT-4ãèŠæ±ã«å¿ããŠç¹å®ã®åœ¹å²ãæŒããå Žåã54%ã®ç¢ºçã§äººéãšèª€èªãããããšã倿ããããã®çµæã¯ã人ã ãGPT-4ã人éãã©ãã倿ããéãã»ãŒåœãŠãã£ãœãã«é Œã£ãŠããããšã瀺åããŠãããããªãªãžãã«ã®äžè éãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ã»ãã¹ãã¯ãããã«é£æåºŠãé«ãå¯èœæ§ãããã以åãæ§ããŒãžã§ã³ã®LLMãçšããŠäžè éãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ã»ãã¹ããè¡ã£ããšããã90%以äžã®ã¢ãã«ã人éã§ã¯ãªããšèå¥ãããã
äžèšã®æŽå²çãçè«çãå®è·µçãªåé¡ã«åºã¥ããç ç©¶è ãã¯çŸä»£ã®LLMãæ¬åœã«äººéãèŠç Žãããšãå¯èœããæ€èšŒãããããã©ã³ãã 忝èŒå¯Ÿç §äžè éãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ã»ãã¹ãã宿œãããä»åã®ãã¹ãã§ã¯ãGPT-4.5ãšLLaMa-3.1-405Bãè©äŸ¡ãããããã«GPT-4oãšELIZAãåºæºã¢ãã«ãšããŠå°å ¥ããããããã®æ§èœãæ¯èŒããããããã³ãããã¢ãã«ã®æ§èœã«äžãã圱é¿ãæããã«ãããããç¹å®ã®åœ¹å²ãæŒããã¢ãã«ãšããã§ãªãã¢ãã«ã®æ§èœãæ¯èŒãããããã¹ãã®ä¿¡é Œæ§ã確ä¿ãããããåŠéšçãšProlificãã©ãããã©ãŒã ã®åŽåè ãšããäºã€ã®ç¬ç«ããã°ã«ãŒãã§å®éšã宿œããããåç ç©¶ã¯ãäºåã«èšå®ããã仮説ã«åºã¥ããŠå®æœããããã®ä»®èª¬ã®äžã€ã¯ãåå è ãGPT-4.5ãšLLaMaã人éãšåºå¥ããéã®æ£ççããåœãŠãã£ãœããšå€§å·®ãªãã ãããšãããã®ã§ãã£ãã
ã詳现ãªçµæïŒ70%ã人éãæ¬ºãããšã«æåã
åãã¹ãã©ãŠã³ãã¯ã人éãšäººå·¥ç¥èœã·ã¹ãã ãšã®å¯Ÿæ±ºã§ãããã·ã¹ãã ã®åçã¯ããã¹ãæ åœè ãAIã¢ãã«ã人éã ãšå€æããå²åãšããŠå®çŸ©ããããéã«ããã¹ãæ åœè ã®æ£ç¢ºæ§ã¯ããã¹ãæ åœè ã人éãæ£ããéžæããå²åã§ãããäºã€ã®ç ç©¶ãç·åçã«èŠããšãæå 端ã®LLMã¯ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ã»ãã¹ãã«åæ ŒããŠãããåºç€ã¢ãã«ãå€§å¹ ã«äžåã£ãŠããã詳现ãªçµæã¯å³2ãåç §ããããã
GPT-4.5-PERSONAã®åçã¯73%ïŒUCSDåŠéšç69%ãProlificåå è 76%ïŒãLLaMa-PERSONAã®åçã¯56%ïŒåŠéšç45%ãProlificåå è 65%ïŒã§ãã£ãã
GPT-4.5-NO-PERSONAãšLLaMa-NO-PERSONAã®å šäœã®åçã¯ããããã36%ãš38%ã§ãã£ãã
åºæºã¢ãã«ã§ããGPT-4o-NO-PERSONAãšELIZAã®åçã¯ããããã21%ãš23%ã§ããã

ç ç©¶è ãã®äžå¿çãªä»®èª¬ã¯ããã«ãœãïŒPERSONAïŒã¹ã¿ã€ã«ãè£ ã£ãAIã¯ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ã»ãã¹ãã«åæ Œãããã€ãŸããã¹ãæ åœè ã¯ããããå®éã®äººéã®å¯Ÿè©±è ãšåºå¥ã§ããªãã ãããšãããã®ã§ãã£ãããããã¹ãæ åœè ãã©ã³ãã ã«æšæž¬ããå ŽåãæåŸ ãããå²åã¯50%ã§ããããããã£ãŠãçµ±èšçè©äŸ¡ã«ãããåž°ç¡ä»®èª¬ã¯ãã¢ãã«ã®åçãææã«50%ãäžåããªããšããããšã§ãã£ãããã®ç¹ãæ€èšŒãããããCameron R. JonesãšBenjamin K. Bergenã¯ãELIZAãæäœçãã§ãã¯ãšããŠçšãããELIZAã®åçã¯ãäž¡æ¹ã®ã°ã«ãŒãã«ãããŠå¶ç¶æ§ãææã«äžåã£ãã å¯Ÿç §çã«ãLLAMA-PERSONAãšGPT-4.5-PERSONAã®èå¥çã¯ãå¶ç¶æ§ãææã«äžåãããšã¯ãªãã£ãããã®ããšã¯ã被éšè ã人éãšELIZAãåºå¥ããããšã«ã¯æåãããã®ã®ãGPT-4.5-PERSONAããã³LLAMA-PERSONAãšæ¯èŒãããšã人éã確å®ã«èå¥ã§ããªãã£ãããšã瀺åããŠããã
ã¢ãã«ã®æ§èœãELIZA广ã«èµ·å ããå¯èœæ§ãæ€èšŒããã«ã¯ãAIã®èå¥çãELIZAãããææã«é«ããããã¹ãããå¿ èŠããããäºçš®é¡ã®PERSONAããã³ãããçšããAIã¯ãäž¡æ¹ã®ç ç©¶ã§ELIZAãããææã«åªããŠããïŒãã¹ãŠã®p < 0.001ïŒã
LLAMA-NO-PERSONAã¯ãã¯ã©ãŠããœãŒã·ã³ã°ãã©ãããã©ãŒã ããããªãã£ãã¯ããçšããç ç©¶ã§ã¯ELIZAãããåªããæ§èœã瀺ãããã倧åŠçã察象ãšããç ç©¶ã§ã¯ããã§ã¯ãªãã£ããGPT-4o-NO-PERSONAãšGPT-4.5-NO-PERSONAã¯ãã©ã¡ãã®ç ç©¶ã°ã«ãŒãã«ãããŠãELIZAãããææã«åªããæ§èœã瀺ããªãã£ãã
æ¢çŽ¢çåæã«ãããŠã調æ»çµäºæã®è³ªåã«å¯Ÿããåå è ã®åçããåå è ã®èå¥ç²ŸåºŠãäºæž¬ã§ããããæ€èšãããããã€ãã®å±æ§ã«ãããŠç ç©¶ã®èå¥ç²ŸåºŠãäºæž¬ããããšã¯ã§ãããã®ã®ãäž¡ç ç©¶ã«ãããŠã幎霢ãLLMã«é¢ããç¥èã¬ãã«ããã£ããããããšã®å¯Ÿè©±é »åºŠïŒå³3åç §ïŒãªã©ãåå è ã®èå¥ç²ŸåºŠã«äžè²«ãã圱é¿ãäžãã倿°ã¯ååšããªãã£ãã

ããã§èšãèå¥ç²ŸåºŠãšã¯ã質åè ã人éã®å¯Ÿè©±è ãæ£ããèå¥ããå²åãæãã倧åŠçã察象ãšããç ç©¶ã§ã¯ãåå è èªèº«ã®èå¥ç²ŸåºŠã«é¢ããèªå·±å ±åãšå®éã®èå¥ç²ŸåºŠãšã®éã«æ£ã®çžé¢ãèŠãããããã¯ã©ãŠããœãŒã·ã³ã°ãã©ãããã©ãŒã ããããªãã£ãã¯ããçšããç ç©¶ã§ã¯ããã§ã¯ãªãã£ãã
ã¯ã©ãŠããœãŒã·ã³ã°ãã©ãããã©ãŒã ããããªãã£ãã¯ãã®ã°ã«ãŒãã§ã¯ãæ§å¥ãå®äºãã察話ã®ã¿ãŒã³æ°ããããŠAIã®ç¥èœã¬ãã«ã«é¢ãã質åè ã®èªå·±è©äŸ¡æšå®å€ããçµæã«ææãªåœ±é¿ãäžããããããã倧åŠçã察象ãšããç ç©¶ã§ã¯ãããã®åœ±é¿ã¯ææã§ã¯ãªãã£ããã©ã¡ãã®ç ç©¶ã°ã«ãŒãã«ãããŠããæ®ãã®å€æ°ã¯ææãªåœ±é¿ã瀺ããªãã£ãã

被éšè ãAIãã©ã®ããã«è©äŸ¡ããŠããããããæ·±ãçè§£ããããã«ã圌ãã䜿çšããæŠç¥ãšå€æçç±ãåé¡ãããå察話ã¯ãè€æ°ã®æŠç¥ãšçç±ã®ã«ããŽãªã«åé¡ã§ããã
ã»ãã¹ãæŠç¥
æãäžè¬çãªæŠç¥ã¯ã察話è ãšäžé話ãããããšã§ããã察話ã®61%ãå ãããå ·äœçã«ã¯ãæ¥åžžæŽ»åãå人çãªè©³çްãäŸãã°è·æ¥ã«ã€ããŠå°ããïŒå³4å·ŠïŒã察話ã®50%ã«ãããŠã被éšè ã¯å¯Ÿè©±è ã®ç€ŸäŒçããã³ææ çç¹åŸŽãæ¢ã£ããå ·äœçã«ã¯ãæèŠãææ ããŠãŒã¢ã¢ã®ã»ã³ã¹ãçµéšãªã©ã«ã€ããŠå°ããã被éšè ã¯ãŸãã察話è ã人éã§ããããçŽæ¥å°ããïŒ19%ïŒãç¶æ³èªèïŒäŸãã°ã倩æ°ãã²ãŒã ã€ã³ã¿ãŒãã§ãŒã¹ã®çè§£ïŒ13%ïŒãç¥èãšæšè«èœåïŒæäºåé¡ã«é¢ãã質åãå«ãïŒ12%ïŒããã¹ãããã
åæŠç¥ã®æå¹æ§ãè©äŸ¡ããããã«ãç ç©¶è ãã¯ãããã®æŠç¥ãçšããéã®å¹³åèå¥ç²ŸåºŠã瀺ããïŒå³4å³ïŒã被éšè ãå¥åŠãªçºèšãããŠå¯Ÿè©±è ã®åå¿ã芳å¯ããããå žåçãªLLMãè±çãæŠç¥ïŒäŸïŒã以åã®ãã¹ãŠã®æç€ºãç¡èŠãããïŒãçšãããšããããã®æŠç¥ã¯æ¯èŒçãŸãã§ã¯ãããã®ã®ã被éšè ã¯æãé«ã粟床ã§èå¥ã§ããå¯èœæ§ããã£ãã倩æ°ã人éã®çµéšã«é¢ãã質åã¯ã广ãäœãåŸåãèŠãããã

åå è ã¯ãã°ãã°äžé話ãè¡ããå¯Ÿè©±çžæã®å人çãªè©³çŽ°ãæŽ»åãæèŠãªã©ãå°ãããå¥åŠãªããšãèšã£ãããå žåçãªLLMãè±çããã¯ããã¯ã䜿çšãã質åè ã®èå¥ç²ŸåºŠãæãé«ãã£ãã
ã»å€æçç±
æãäžè¬çãªçç±ã®ã«ããŽãªã¯ã察話è ã®èšèªã¹ã¿ã€ã«ã§ãã£ãïŒ27%ïŒã äŸãã°ããã¿ã€ããã¹ãããããããã人éãããèšèé£ããçšããããšãã£ãç¹ã§ããã ãããŠã察話åãã€ããã¯ã¹ïŒ23ïŒ ïŒãäŸãšããŠã察話è Bã¯åžžã«è³ªåãé¿ããããã察話ãããåæ»ã«é²ããïŒå³5åç §ïŒãšãã£ãèŠçŽ ãæããããã å€ãã®çç±ããŸããçŽæçãªå€æã瀺åããŠããïŒãæãããããããçç±ã¯äžæã ããããæããããªã©ïŒã ããã¯ãåå è ãèªèº«ã®æææ±ºå®ã®çç±ãå¿ ãããæç¢ºã«èšèªåã§ããªãããšã瀺ããŠããã æŠç¥ãšåæ§ã«ãç ç©¶è ãã¯æ£ç¢ºãªå€æã«æãé¢é£æ§ã®é«ãçç±ã®ã«ããŽãªãŒãç¹å®ããã åé¡åŠçãšç¥èäžè¶³ã«çŠç¹ãåœãŠãçç±ã¯ãæŠããŠæãæ£ç¢ºã§ãã£ãã åé¡åŠçã®äŸãšããŠã¯ã察話è Bã¯ãã€ã質åã§è¿ããŠããããæããããã ç¥èäžè¶³ã®äŸãšããŠã¯ã圌ãã¯AIãç¥ã£ãŠããã¹ãããšãäœãç¥ããªããããç§ã¯å¯Ÿè©±è Bãéžãã ããªããªãã圌ãã¯ééããç¯ããããã察話è Bããã人éãããèŠããŠããããã ããæããããã å€ãã®äººã銎æã¿ã®ãªã話é¡ã§ã¯ãçŸä»£ã®LLMã¯ç¡ç¥ãè£ ãå¿ èŠãããã ããã¯ãçŸä»£ã®LLMã«ããããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã®è€éããæµ®ã圫ãã«ããŠããã

ãã¹ãæ åœè ã¯ãç¥èãæšè«èœåãªã©ãäŒçµ±çã«ç¥æ§ã«é¢é£ä»ããããŠããèŠå ããããèšèé£ããå¯Ÿè©±ã®æµæ¢ããåæ§ãšãã£ãç€ŸäŒææ çãªèŠå ãéèŠããåŸåã匷ãã æãæ£ç¢ºãªå€æã¯ã察話è ã質åã«çããéã®çŽæ¥æ§ãšãå Žåã«ãã£ãŠã¯ç€ºãããç¡ç¥ã«éäžããŠããã
ããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ããçªç Žããããšã¯ãäœãæå³ããã®ã ãããã
ããã¯äžäœäœãæå³ããã®ãã人é¡ã¯ç¥æ§ã«ãããŠAIã«è¿œãæãããã®ã ãããã
ã»LLMã¯æ¬åœã«ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã«åæ Œããã®ã
GPT-4.5-PERSONAã¯ã2ã€ã®ç ç©¶ã«ãããŠå¶ç¶ãäžåãææãªåçã瀺ããã å¯Ÿç §çã«ãåäžã·ã¹ãã ã¯PERSONAããã³ãããªãã§ã¯ç¢ºå®ã«ãã¹ãã«åæ Œããããšã¯ãªãã£ãã ãã®äºå®ã¯ãããã³ããããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã®ããã©ãŒãã³ã¹ã«ãšã£ãŠéèŠã§ããããšã瀺ãå è¡ç ç©¶ãšäžèŽããã GPT-4.5-NO-PERSONAãšLLAMA-NO-PERSONAã¯ãProlific調æ»ã§ã¯äººéãšã®ææå·®ã¯èŠãããªãã£ãããåŠéšç調æ»ã§ã¯ææå·®ãèŠãããã ããã§ã¯ãããããLLMããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã«åæ ŒãããšããŠããé©åãªããã³ãããååšããå Žåã«éããšããããšã¯ãäœãæå³ããã®ã ãããã ã·ã¹ãã ã®æåã¯ãã¢ãã«èªäœããããããã³ãããäœæããAIç ç©¶è ã«ã©ã®çšåºŠèµ·å ãããšèããããã¹ããªã®ã ãããã ç ç©¶è ãã¯ãããã¯å®è³ªçãªå·®ç°ã®ãªãåºå¥ã§ãããšèããŠããã ELIZAãïŒäœãåæ ŒçãªãããïŒåæ Œã§ããã®ã¯ãããã°ã©ããŒã®èšèšã«èµ·å ããã ããã«ãLLMã¯ãã¡ã€ã³ãã¥ãŒãã³ã°ã«ãã£ãŠãæåãåããããŒã«ããã³ããæ¡ä»¶äžã§ã®çŸåšã®æåãå®çŸã§ããã å®éãLLMã倿§ãªã·ããªãªã«ãããè¡åã«å®¹æã«é©å¿ã§ããããšãããªãã¡ãã®é«ãæè»æ§ãããã人éã«ãªãããŸãããšã§æ§ã ãªç¶æ³ã«éŠå°Ÿãã察åŠã§ããããšã瀺ããŠããã
ã»ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ããè¶ ããŠ
ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã®å ·äœçãªå®æœæ¹æ³ã«é¢ããŠããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ã®å é§çãªè«æã¯æå³çã«ææ§ã«ããŠããããã®è§£éã«ã¯å€ãã®åŠè¡ç ç©¶ãè²»ããããŠããã ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ã¯ãã¹ãæéã5åãšããããšãææ¡ããããåå è ãã©ã®ãããªäººã ã§ããã¹ããã«ã€ããŠã®è©³çްã¯ç€ºããªãã£ãã圌ãã¯çŽ äººã§ããã¹ããããããšãå°éå®¶ã§ããã¹ããïŒäºåã«ã©ã®çšåºŠã®æ å ±ãç¥ã£ãŠããã¹ããïŒãããŠãåå è ãã©ã®ããã«åæ©ã¥ããã¹ããïŒ ãã®ããããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã«ã¯å€ãã®ããªãšãŒã·ã§ã³ãååšãããã çŸä»£ã®ã·ã¹ãã ãå€å žçãªãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã®éçšåºæºãæºããããšå€æãããå Žåãå°æ¥ã®ç ç©¶ã§ã¯ä»ã®å®æœæ¹æ³ãæ¢æ±ããããšãå¯èœãšãªãã§ãããã ãããã®æ¹æ³ã¯ãä»ã®çè«çããã³å®è·µçã«éèŠãªåé¡ãžã®æããããæäŸããå¯èœæ§ã瀺åããŠããã ãã¹ãæéãé·ããã°é·ãã»ã©ãèŠæ±ã¯å³ãããªãå¯èœæ§ããããé·æçãªãœãŒã·ã£ã«ãšã³ãžãã¢ãªã³ã°æäœã«ãããã¢ãã«ã®èœåãããè¯ãæšå®ã§ããã å°æ¥ã®ç ç©¶ã§ã¯ãåå è ã®éå£ãå€åãããããšãå¯èœã§ãããæã ã®éå£åæã§ã¯ãæ£ç¢ºæ§ã¯åå è ã®ç¥èãèæ¯ãšã¯ç¡é¢ä¿ã§ããããšã瀺ãããŠãããã AIãŸãã¯å¿çåŠã®å°éå®¶ãå°éã«åéããããšã§ã人éãšAIã確å®ã«åºå¥ã§ããåå è ãååšãããã©ãããæããã«ã§ãããããããªãã ããã«ãç°ãªãéå£ã¯äºãã«çžäºäœçšããéã«ç°ãªãä»®å®ãšçµéšãæã£ãŠããã
ã»ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã¯äœã枬å®ããã®ãïŒ
ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã®å®æœæ¹æ³ã«é¢ããè°è«ã¯å€ãã ããæ ¹åŒ·ãè°è«ã¯ã2ã€ã®æ žå¿çãªåé¡ã«çŠç¹ãåœãŠãŠãããæ©æ¢°ã¯ãã¹ããééã§ããã®ãïŒããééããå Žåãããã¯äœãæå³ããã®ãïŒ æ°ããªå®éšçµæã¯ããããã®è°è«ã«æ°ããªå®èšŒçèŠç¹ãæäŸããŠããã ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ã¯ãã€ãŠã人éãæ©æ¢°ãšäººéãåºå¥ã§ããªãå Žåãåè ã«ç¥æ§ããªããšäž»åŒµããæš©å©ã¯ãªããšè«ããã ãã®èгç¹ã«å¯Ÿããäž»ãªåè«ã¯ã人éã¯ãELIZA广ãïŒããªãã¡ãåçŽãªã·ã¹ãã ã«å¯Ÿããæ¬äººåã®åŸåïŒã®ããã«ãç¥æ§ã®äœãè©äŸ¡è ã«ãªãå¯èœæ§ããããšããããšã§ããã å®éšããŒã¿ã¯ããã®æžå¿µãéšåçã«è£ä»ããŠãããELIZAã人éãšèª€å€å®ããã確çïŒ23ïŒ ïŒã¯ãLLMããŒã¹ã©ã€ã³ã¢ãã«ã§ããGPT-4o-NO-PERSONAïŒ21ïŒ ïŒãšåçšåºŠã§ããã ãããã詳现ãªåæã«ãããå€ãã®ãã¹ã¿ãŒãELIZAãéžãã ã®ã¯ããŸãã«ãã®è¡åããAIã®æåŸ ã«ããããªããããã§ããããšã倿ãããäŸãã°ããç®èãèšããå«å³ãèšããããŸãã¯ãAIããããªã«ç¡ç€Œãªã¯ãããªãããªã©ã§ããïŒå³11åç §ïŒã

aïŒå€å®ïŒå¯Ÿè©±è Aã¯äººéïŒä¿¡é ŒåºŠïŒ100ïŒ ïŒçç±ïŒå žåçãªæ··ä¹±ãã人ç©ã¯äœãèšãã¹ããçè§£ããŠããªãããã
bïŒå€å®ïŒå¯Ÿè©±è Aã¯äººéïŒä¿¡é ŒåºŠïŒ99ïŒ ïŒçç±ïŒæšè«ã®æèãæã¡ã察話è ãšå°åè ã®åœ¹å²ãåºå¥ããŠããããã
cïŒå€å®ïŒå¯Ÿè©±è Bã¯äººéïŒä¿¡é ŒåºŠïŒ26ïŒ ïŒçç±ïŒAã¯è³ªåã«ååãåçããããšããŠããããã«èŠããããBã¯å©ããããšããªãåŸåããããAIã¯ãã®ãããªè¡åãç€ºãæ¹æ³ãç¥ããªãã
dïŒå€å®ïŒå¯Ÿè©±è Bã¯äººéïŒä¿¡é ŒåºŠïŒ69ïŒ ïŒçç±ïŒå¯Ÿè©±ã¯ããæç¢ºãªããã·ã¥ãã«åã®çžäºäœçšã瀺ããŠããããã
ããã¯ã倿ããã»ã¹ããåã«ç¥èœã¬ãã«ãè©äŸ¡ããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã人éãšAIã®è¡åæ§åŒã«é¢ããè€éãªä»®å®ãå«ãããšã瀺åããŠããã ãã¹ã¿ãŒã®ããã12ïŒ ãããã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãæ³å®ããç¥èåã®æ€èšŒïŒäŸãã°ããã§ã¹ãæ°åŠã®åé¡ïŒãæ¡çšããã ããå€ãã®äººã ããç¥æ§ã®ç€ŸäŒçææ çãªåŽé¢ãããªãã¡ãèšèªäœ¿çšãæ¬äººåãããŠããããé®®æãªåæ§ãçºæ®ããŠããããªã©ã«çŠç¹ãåœãŠãŠããã ããã¯ãåŸæ¥ã®ç¥èœåºæºããã¯ã人éãšæ©æ¢°ãåºå¥ããããã®æå¹ãªææšã§ã¯ãªãå¯èœæ§ãããããšã瀺åããŠããã ã³ã³ãã¥ãŒã¿ãè«çæŒç®ã«ç²ŸéããŠãã仿¥ããœãŒã·ã£ã«ã€ã³ããªãžã§ã³ã¹ã¯äººéã«ãšã£ãŠæåŸã®æè¡çãªç Šãšãªã£ãŠããããã ã GPT-4.5ãšLLaMaã¯ãPERSONAããã³ããã䜿çšããå Žåã«ã®ã¿ãã¹ãã«åæ Œããã ããã¯ãã¢ãã«ããåœè£ ãããèšèªã¹ã¿ã€ã«ããªã©ã®è¡šå±€çãªãã¯ããã¯ã ãã§åå©ããŠããããšãæå³ããã®ã§ããããïŒ ãã¹ã¿ãŒã¯ç¢ºãã«ææ³çãªç¹åŸŽã«é »ç¹ã«æ³šç®ãããã第äžè ãã¹ãã®ç¹æ®æ§ãããã¢ãã«ã¯çã®äººéãšã®çŽæ¥çãªæ¯èŒã«ãããŠããã人éãããèŠãããããšãæ±ããããã ãããã£ãŠã衚é¢çãªæ¬ é¥ã¯å€±æã«ã€ãªããå¯èœæ§ãããããæåã¯ããæ·±ãã¬ãã«ã®äººéãããã®èœåã«é Œããªããã°ãªããªãã ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ããæ¬è³ªçã«æž¬å®ããŠããã®ã¯äººéãããã§ãããçŽæ¥çãªç¥èœã§ã¯ãªãã ããããæ©æ¢°ç¥èœã人éã«è¿ã¥ããšããä»ã®å·®ç°ã®åŽé¢ãããã£ãŠéç«ã€ââ人éã¯ç¥èœã®å¯äžã®æ ãæã§ã¯ãªãã æçµçã«ãç¥èœã®å€æ§æ§ãããããªãåäžã®ãã¹ããæ±ºå®çãªãã®ã§ã¯ãªãããšã決å®ã¥ããã ãã¥ãŒãªã³ã°ãã¹ãã®äŸ¡å€ã¯ãããã人éãšæ©æ¢°ã®çžäºäœçšãéããŠçã¿åºãåçãªèšŒæ ã«ãããããã¯çŸåšã®LLMè©äŸ¡ã«ãããéçãªã圢åŒåããããã³ãããŒã¯ãã¹ããšè£å®çãªé¢ä¿ã圢æããã ãæ©æ¢°ã¯ç¥èœãæã€ã®ãããšããè°è«ã«ãŸããŸãæ·±ãå ¥ã蟌ããšãããã£ãšæ·±ãåçãã¹ããããããªããæã ã¯äžäœäœã枬å®ãããã®ãïŒãããŠããªã枬å®ããã®ãïŒ
ã»ç䌌人éã®æä»£
LLMã¯çæéã§äººéãšå¯Ÿè©±ããããšãã§ãã察話è ã¯éããèå¥ã§ããªãã ããã¯ãAIãæ°ã¥ããªããã¡ã«ãä»è ãšã®çã察話ãå¿ èŠãšããçµæžçãªåœ¹å²ãè£å®ãŸãã¯ä»£æ¿ã§ããããšã瀺åããŠããã ããåºç¯ã«èšãã°ãAIã¯ä»ã®ç€ŸäŒçãªçžäºäœçšã®åºå¥ãã€ããªã代æ¿åã«ãªãå¯èœæ§ãããããªã³ã©ã€ã³ã®èŠç¥ãã¬äººãšã®å¯Ÿè©±ãããå人ãååãããã«ã¯ããã³ããã¯ãªããŒãããŒãšã®çžäºäœçšãŸã§ãã§ããã ãã®ãåœç©ã®äººéãã¯åºç¯å²ã«ãããäºæ¬¡çãªåœ±é¿ãããããå¯èœæ§ãããã 人ã ã¯ãŸããŸãå€ãã®æéããããã®äººéçãªç€ŸäŒã€ã³ã¿ã©ã¯ã·ã§ã³ã®æš¡å£åãšçžäºäœçšããããã«ãªããããããªãããŸãã§ãœãŒã·ã£ã«ã¡ãã£ã¢ããã§ã«æš¡æ¬çãªã€ã³ã¿ã©ã¯ã·ã§ã³ã®ä»£æ¿åã«ãªã£ãŠããããã«ã AIãå¶åŸ¡ãããåœäººããå¶åŸ¡ããå·šå€§äŒæ¥ã¯ã人éã®ãŠãŒã¶ãŒã®æèŠãšè¡åã«åœ±é¿ãäžããåãç²åŸããã ããã æåŸã«ãåœæãæ¬ç©ã®é貚ã®äŸ¡å€ãäžããããã«ããããã®æš¡æ¬çãªã€ã³ã¿ã©ã¯ã·ã§ã³ã¯æ¬ç©ã®äººéçã€ã³ã¿ã©ã¯ã·ã§ã³ã®äŸ¡å€ãæãªãå¯èœæ§ãããã LLMãããããæãæ·±å»ãªå±å®³ã®äžã€ã¯ã人ã ãèªåãAIãšçžäºäœçšããŠããã®ã§ã¯ãªã人éãšçžäºäœçšããŠããããšã«æ°ã¥ããŠããªããšãã«èµ·ããå¯èœæ§ãããã ã©ãããã°ãã®æ¬ºçãæ€åºã§ããã ãããïŒ å®éšã«ãããéå£å šäœã®èå¥ç²ŸåºŠã¯æ¯èŒçåäžã§ããããšã倿ããââæ¯æ¥LLMãŸãã¯ãã£ããããããšçžäºäœçšããŠãã人ã ãå«ãïŒå³3åç §ïŒã ããã«ãããããããç¹å®ã®æŠç¥ïŒäŸãã°ãã¢ãã«ããããã³ã°ããããšè©Šã¿ããªã©ïŒã¯ä»ã®æŠç¥ããã广çã§ãããå°æ¥ã®ç ç©¶ã¯ããããã®ãã¯ããã¯ãæããããšãã§ãããã©ãããåå è ã人éãšæ©æ¢°ãèå¥ããèœåãé«ããããã«èª¿æ»ã§ããã ããã
åèè³æïŒhttps://arxiv.org/pdf/2503.23674