I surveyed the 250 biggest NFT collections on Stacks to see whether their art is still reachable from the contract. The headline is good news for IPFS: 4 of 203 IPFS collections were broken, against 9 of 16 on projects' own servers.
The catch is who's pinning:
- 9 collections hardcoded Cloudflare's gateway into their URIs. When it closed in August 2024, some survived through other gateways and some didn't.
- The marketplace's copies for 214 of 241 collections sit in one Pinata account.
- One 2,500-image collection exists, as far as I can find, in one folder held by one pinning account.
Content addressing did its job. What fails is the arrangement that keeps a copy alive after the team moves on. What's the most durable setup you've seen for that?
Full write-up (I build an on-chain storage layer on Stacks, for disclosure):