Life is Strange™

Life is Strange™

View Stats:
What Happens To The Present From The Perspective Of Others?
Like when Max decides to time travel through photos and then she alters the past. Do they suddenly just forget and have the new memories of the altered timeline? Or is it like a separate continuity that exists whereas the changed reality is its own thing? Even if the latter is the case, does Max just teleport into the photo, or she just stands there frozen for a bit and then an alternate Max takes over the consciousness?
< >
Showing 1-5 of 5 comments
The details of how Max's photo-editing power work aren't fully explored, but we see:

- In the new/changed timeline, there has always been a version of Max who acts appropriately for that timeline, from the moment Max left the past to the moment Max arrives in the present. For example, when William doesn't die, we see a Max that joined the Vortex Club; when she undoes that change, we see that she and Chloe did stuff during the night Max spent with the other version of Chloe. I like to call the version of Max that takes over apparently without memory of being a future version of herself "Auto-Max".

- The version of Max we follow has no memory of Auto-Max's thoughts and actions, having to piece together what happened from context clues, diary entries, and maybe the snapshots of the new timeline we see while Max is returning to the present (it's never explained whether that's something Max experiences, or just something for the player).

- Like with the rewind power, other characters never show any signs of remembering anything from the previous version of the timeline - any awareness they have of other histories comes from Max telling them.

- The Nightmare sequence hints at the other timelines existing in some sense, but it's not clear how much of that sequence is "real" and how much is Max's imagination.

- Double Exposure shows that parallel-but-connected timelines can be a thing, but it also doesn't work with the time-travel mechanics from the first game.

So, if we assume that Max creates a new timeline with her photo-editing power, and the old history is still out there somewhere, then an observer would spying on Max throughout her life, would see the same Max acting consistently until the photo was taken, maybe a moment when Max is disoriented, then Max acting differently for a few minutes, then another moment of disorientation (end of the photo's "window"), before Max acts consistently for a significant period, though possibly without memory of what she did while acting differently, or maybe just without memory of why she acted that way, followed by a third moment of disorientation (Max returning to the present) and Max acting differently, and like she has forgotten a number of things that happened since the second disorientation, and remembers things that didn't happen.

Of course, if we assume that there's only a single timeline, which gets overwritten, then the hypothetical spy watching Max's life would remember seeing the same things, even if those memories were only retconned in.

If we assume that when Max undoes saving William, that restores the original timeline (or returns her to that timeline) rather than creating a third version, then our spy would have seen Max staring at that photo for a bit before spending the evening doing investigator stuff with Chloe, sleeping over, and then randomly hugging Chloe and acting like she'd forgotten what happened overnight.

It's a lot less noticeable for other people than Max's rewind power, where, to a third party, Max appears to teleport from where she was originally to where she was when she rewound, and items teleport from wherever they were to her hands/pockets/bag/wherever she keeps her inventory...
Ok but you never answered what happens from an observer when Max time travels via photos. Like when Warren knows about Max's abilities and she uses it, does she still stand there and auto-Max takes over, or she just vanishes into thin air as if being sucked into a portal by the photo? This is under the assumption that there's only a single timeline that is being altered, so obviously for parallel timelines that can be explained as auto-Max taking over while the real Max goes back in time. The hypothetical spy's memories being retconned does make sense but that seems more of a cop-out answer.

It also never made sense to me that Maxine could teleport herself when rewinding the first time, but then can never do that again unless she focuses on photos. And then objects staying with her after rewinding I guess is explained as gameplay mechanic, same with the altered past allowing Max to fast forward her consciousness to the present. Let's be honest here, nobody is gonna wanna replay the same chapters over again every time the story is altered, so the developers just showed those screenshots for convenience. Kind of weird that Jefferson would even have photos of Max when he read her diary and knows about her time travelling powers.
Originally posted by Amanda Reena:
Ok but you never answered what happens from an observer when Max time travels via photos. Like when Warren knows about Max's abilities and she uses it, does she still stand there and auto-Max takes over, or she just vanishes into thin air as if being sucked into a portal by the photo?
For a single timeline being rewritten, that version of Warren no longer exists as soon as Max enters the photo - or at least we don't see anything that suggests that time passes in the present while Max is in the past, so I assume the change is instant in the present.
!Spojler! At the end of the game, Max has this weird nightmarenish vision where she flirts with Jefferson. Right before, she and Chloe are heading to the light house; after her vision, Chloe says something about "Real Max being back" so we can assume she physically is there but does not act like herself. My theory is that her acting while having visions is similar to sleepwalking. However, when it comes to time travelling, the most important information that is stated in the game is given to us through evil Max from real Max's nightmare. She says "Think about all the versions you left behind" (or sth close to it). Since the whole game is about butterfly effect and how it changes reality, every decision is suppose to split reality in two. For example you have decision to do sth and the moment you decide to DO sth the reality in which you DID NOT do that starts to exist. So when Max's decides to go back in time the reality in which she stays exists as well and that is what I believe is happening. One version of Max's is going back and the other stays. She just splits in two. By going back in time she creates new paraller universes in which other versions of Maxs exist and they also make their own decisions. It's an evergoing cycle.
Originally posted by BlackiV316:
She says "Think about all the versions you left behind" (or sth close to it). Since the whole game is about butterfly effect and how it changes reality, every decision is suppose to split reality in two. For example you have decision to do sth and the moment you decide to DO sth the reality in which you DID NOT do that starts to exist. So when Max's decides to go back in time the reality in which she stays exists as well and that is what I believe is happening. One version of Max's is going back and the other stays. She just splits in two. By going back in time she creates new paraller universes in which other versions of Maxs exist and they also make their own decisions. It's an evergoing cycle.
that's only valid for the many worlds interpretation, not if we go by a single timeline
< >
Showing 1-5 of 5 comments
Per page: 1530 50