I went to Island Beach on Wednesday to start a completely (in the spirit of the times) unscientific experiment: I wanted to compare my birding results on my own compared to the list I'd compile when Shari & I went on Scott's NJ Audubon trip today. Of course, this disregards weather, winds, different habitats, and time spent birding, but I just wanted to see. On Wednesday I did piss poor--the only two interesting birds I saw were my FOS Red-breasted Nuthatch in the parking lot of Swimming Beach 1 and my FOY Marbled Godwit on a sand bar at the Winter Anchorage. I barely broke 30 species for the 3 plus hours I spent there.
Today started out slow; our first stop, the Tidal Pond Trail, yielded very few birds, and half of those I missed. It confirmed what I already know--I pass by a lot of birds that someone with quicker eyes and ears can pick up. We looked at the beach from the Swimming Lot 1 but there was zilch there--which sort of made me feel better, since I a) hate standing in one spot looking at a blank ocean and b) the last time I did it on my own, the ocean was equally blank so it's not just me.
However, during a walk around the edges of the parking lots I garnered my accomplishment for the day. In a thicket of bushes there were 3 birds. Two of them were House Finches, and not even good-looking males, but either drab juveniles or females. The third bird and couple of us were looking at was more problematic. It was hard to get a decent look at the bird through the leaves and twigs, but I was able to put it together in parts--building a bird, as a friend once described it. It had an eye ring, then I saw brown feathers on the back, and after another little hop, I saw yellow on the breast--Dickcissel. Not a year bird, but a county bird and a rarity in Ocean County. Unfortunately, not too many others got on the bird though I think everyone heard its flatulent call which confirmed the sighting.
Warblers were at a premium today--something about the winds being northeast, and of the warblers being called out, I probably missed half of them. I did manage parula, Palm Warbler, yellow warbler, and redstart, but missed a lot of others--at least Shari also got Black-and-white Warbler and Magnolia Warbler on her list.
One of the most entertaining moments came on the kayak access trail at A15. One of our number spotted a Baltimore Oriole and Rose-breasted Grosbeak right next to each other in the same dead tree. They moved around but kept to the dead branches of trees so all could see them, joined eventually by yet another oriole. I said that in all my time birding, this was the first time I'd ever seen an oriole and grosbeak in the same tree--my friend Bob scoffed but hey, I have a hard enough time seeing either of those species, never mind them associating.
For some odd reason, we when go to the Visitor's Center to have lunch, the parking lot there usually yields up an interesting bird--once, on a trip I didn't attend, an Ash-throated Flycatcher was found, and they couldn't text me fast enough to gloat. Today, however, it was just a Philadelphia Vireo that popped up in a tree. I suspect that every Philadelphia Vireo I've seen in Ocean County has been at Island Beach. (I just checked: true.)
We took a walk on the Johnnie Allen Cove trail, across the road from the Visitor's Center and again, the warblers and were darting in and out of the reeds and groundsel. The bay itself was empty, but on our way back Scott spotted by far the best bird of the trip--a Lark Sparrow smack dab in the middle of the trail. The problem with a trail like Johnnie Allen is that it is too narrow for everyone to line up abreast, so people have to work their way to the front and those who have seen the bird have to yield their spot. It can be frustrating if you're lagging behind in the back. Fortunately, both Shari & I were near the front and got good looks at the bird. I was particularly happy, because this is one of the few birds I actually chased this year (down at Brig) and failed to find.
We made the obligatory stop at Spizzle Creek and found most of our egrets and herons for the day. The final stop (for Shar & me at least) was the Winter Anchorage, where we scoped the sand bars, or what there was of them. If anyone can figure out the tides at Island Beach, there is a prize from the Oceanographic Society--it was supposed to be low tide by then but sure didn't seem like it. I set up our scope and immediately called out to Shari--"I've got oystercatchers." Oystercatchers are, as we all know, Shari's favorite bird. She was looking through the scope when one of the newer birders on the trip turned to me and said, "How do you know they're not clamming?" I didn't understand what he meant. "Say again." "How do you know they're not clamming?" and he pointed to some distant people out on the edge of the Sedge Islands. I was still perplexed but then suddenly the penny dropped--"An oystercatcher is a bird," I told him. He'd never seen one, so Shari put them in the scope and he looked. If you haven't seen one before, it seems like an unlikely bird.
That concluded the entertainment portion of our program.
For the day I managed 43 species-- better than Wednesday but not nearly as many as I have in the past on these trips, but everyone seems to agree that the pickings are slim of late. Still, two year birds and a county bird made it a good trip.
44 species
Blue-winged Teal 2 Spizzle
Green-winged Teal 9 Johnnie Allen
Mourning Dove 3
American Oystercatcher 30
Black-bellied Plover 50
Semipalmated Plover 2
Short-billed Dowitcher 1 Winter anchorage
Greater Yellowlegs 1 Winter anchorage
Laughing Gull 75
American Herring Gull 50
Great Black-backed Gull 4
Lesser Black-backed Gull 1 Swim beach 1
Black Skimmer 100 Winter anchorage
Caspian Tern 2
Forster's Tern 1
Royal Tern 100
Double-crested Cormorant 5
Tricolored Heron 4
Snowy Egret 1
Great Egret 4
Great Blue Heron 11
Osprey 6
Northern Flicker 3
Merlin 4
Eastern Wood-Pewee 1
Eastern Phoebe 1
Philadelphia Vireo 1
Red-eyed Vireo 1
Common Raven 2 Spizzle lot
Carolina Chickadee 2
Tree Swallow 2
Gray Catbird 2
Cedar Waxwing 1
House Sparrow 8
House Finch 7
Lark Sparrow 1
Song Sparrow 2
Baltimore Oriole 2
American Redstart 3
Northern Parula 1
Northern Yellow Warbler 1 Johnnie Allen
Palm Warbler 5
Rose-breasted Grosbeak 1
Dickcissel 1