Repository navigation
Closed
Description
(Placeholder issue for msc thesis)
Problem statement

(Musicians/artists/creators) receive low compensation for publishing their content.
- Typical cut of revenue: (distributor: Spotify/iTunes/Google Play/...)
Signed records: 25% distributor 55% label 20% artist
Unsigned records: 40% distributor 60% artist - Smaller artists get low revenue, due to the "pro rata" model applied by e.g. Spotify. A user-centric model should be more fair (economics/business, less CS)
- The distributor could censor tracks
- Platform lock-in
Existing and upcoming solutions
Blockchain-based solutions exist for music streaming services. At least two start-ups attempted.
- OPUS Audio "Helps artist generate the revenue they deserve".
It uses IPFS for distributed file storage, but actually uses a back-up off-chain database for performance purposes. Strategy for IPFS nodes: OPUS deploys its own nodes around the globe for low latency.
OPUS uses Ethereum smart contracts. Using smart contracts, "[consumers] can rest assured almost 100% of the payments are delivered to the artists transparently, immutably and without intermediaries taking large chunks of revenueβ. - Musicoin project
encourages independent artists to register and publish their work on its own blockchain-based platform. Very interesting: consumers have a free service without ads, while artists get paid (in $MUSIC)
Uses earn-per-play smart contracts based on preset fees each time a song gets played (for >s seconds). Consumers can also tip artists (micropayments).
Uses mining in the form of bitcoin. - Mycelia project is not a streaming service on its own but does provide "creative passport" technology: a digital container with authorization of work, acknowledgements, payment mechanisms and metadata.
Shortcomings of these solutions
- Musicoin pay-per-play system depends entirely on investors and the price of its non-stable currency. If its currency becomes worthless then the artists also receive low revenue.
- OPUS deploys nodes itself and consumer pay a (small) fee for this infrastructure (different from Tribler/torrents)
The dream: a good decentralized streaming system
- A (torrent) streaming technology as fast as spotify, based on a p2p file sharing system (tribler? IPFS?). Challenge: seeders for content with small popularity. To think about: are bandwidth tokens enough incentive?
- Proof of authorship on the blockchain Proof of Authorship on GigaChannel with TrustChainΒ tribler#4144
- (Near) 100% of fees from consumers go directly to the artists they listen to.
- Payouts with stablecoin (USDT/EURS)
- Tipping system/micropayments
- Effective sharing and recommendation systems
Completed reading list
- How the blockchain is disrupting the art economy as we know it (2017)
- de Vos, M., & Pouwelse, J. (2018). A Blockchain-based Micro-Economy of Bandwidth Tokens. CompSys 2018.
- Blockchain is changing how media and entertainment companies compete
- Zhang, B. (2018). Credit Mining: An Incentive and Boosting System in a Peer-to-Peer File-sharing Network.
Reacted by ProphetZarquon, Bulat Nasrulin and Benjamin Lupton
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels
Activity
synctext commentedon Feb 21, 2020
Brainstorm on direction:
Work from now 15 years ago Wi-Fi Walkman: A wireless handhold that shares and recommend music on peer-to-peer networks

Upcoming sprint: document related_work.tex in thesis wording?
Tim-W commentedon Feb 28, 2020
Looked up more decentralized music streaming services:
IMO services only using non-stablecoins can be disregarded. They build a platform and launch their own token/coin which hopes to gain value (hard to say for future).
Conclusion: None of these applications pay near-100% of profits to artists in "real" money (eur/usd)
Tim-W commentedon Mar 5, 2020
(Work in progress) related_work.tex
Tim-W commentedon Mar 6, 2020
Updated the tex with a summary of current decentralized audio streaming services, and decentralized content delivery networks.
Also, possible future directions:
synctext commentedon Mar 6, 2020
Feedback on progress:
Tim-W commentedon Mar 6, 2020
Reading:
design and analysis of a large-scale P2P-VoD system,β SIGCOMM
Comput. Commun. Rev., vol. 38, no. 4, pp. 375β388, 2008.
Tim-W commentedon Mar 6, 2020
From my perspective, depending on time constraints/progress I could try system 1 or system 2 (using a DAO):
System 1: fairness for artists, any files
Challenges:
System 2: fairness for artists, music streaming
Additional challenges:
Tim-W commentedon Mar 20, 2020
Change in relation to my most recent comment:
The system:
A music streaming and/or file sharing DAO where users can donate to artists. (near) 100% of those donations are received (near) instantly by the artist. Artists can prove which content is theirs so that the correct artist receives the donation.
synctext commentedon Mar 21, 2020
cool!
btw Both Bitcoin and Libtorrent have now been integrated in DelftDAO. That saves you lots of engineering.
synctext commentedon Mar 24, 2020
@Tim-W online for sprint update?
Tim-W commentedon Mar 25, 2020
Sorry, I have not been able to make much progress in the recent weeks.. (see my email) I will give an update before the coming Tuesday
Tim-W commentedon Mar 28, 2020
@synctext Sprint update:
Trying to define a better problem statement:
Problem statement updated, split up into 4 subproblems:
any good paid audio streaming service refers to any of the spotify/google play/itunes that provide seamless experience and a large amount of content.
A possible (dreamy) solution:
Progress
Read most of Mitchell Olsthoorn's FBase thesis
Read The DAO whitepaper
Trustchain superapp: Inspected docs, code, ran the app.
Kotlin-ipv8: Inspected docs, code.
Plans
Coming days: fork superapp, create a DAO, upload&share audio/music metadata with peers on an IPv8 app.
Coming week: Find more papers about fast music (torrent) streaming. Then: describe the "dreamy" solution in a more technical system, describe what the "MusicDAO" should be able to do, and predict feasibility for thesis.
Tim-W commentedon Mar 30, 2020
Forked IPv8 superapp, wrote some code, added my own very simple app to it.


* Followed [TrustChainTutorial](https://github.com/Tribler/kotlin-ipv8/blob/master/doc/TrustChainTutorial.md) to get hands on with trustchain interactions. Content on trustchain: "Artist" publishes a track with a track id, name, magnet link. Others can validate whether the content is a duplicate (simple identity theft resilience)Tim-W commentedon Apr 1, 2020
@synctext Can you link me to the project for bitcoin/libtorrent integration in DelftDAO?
85 remaining items
synctext commentedon Jan 22, 2021
That graph is good thesis stuff!
Tim-W commentedon Jan 26, 2021
Last 2 weeks:
Still to do:
synctext commentedon Jan 26, 2021
Tim-W commentedon Jan 28, 2021
New graphs, that show the transaction success of our bitcoin blockchain environment.
(Cumulative) artist income vs. bitcoin block count
(Cumulative) transactions vs. bitcoin block count
Expected releases vs. simulations - versus network size
Last couple of days: did a few more experiments and created more graphs for latency, throughput of certain activities in MusicDAO. Mostly working on evaluation.tex now.
(5+ pages as of 04/02/20201)
Update 05/02/2021 made some improvements to implementation and evaluation
Update 06/02/2021 added keywords and empty sections for things I still want to (at least) write. There is a long section I can write as Future work. Where should this be placed? Evaluation or Conclusion, or as chapter inbetween?
Update 10/02-2021 Updated title. Added several things to intro end evaluation, fig. 4.5, sections 1.4, 4.10, table 1.1. Updated conclusion with section titles.
Update 11/02-2021 Add short sec. on transaction fees in Evaluation.
Thesis version can be found here (40 pages), direct link: https://github.com/Tim-W/msc-thesis/raw/master/report.pdf
Tim-W commentedon Feb 10, 2021
Update 10/02/2021 created MusicDAO demo video
Currently 1:27 minutes, could remove some stuff. It is not very professional, but it does show all its functionalities in quite a short time. Also, I'm working on a better render with higher FPS. Advice welcome, I am not a video editor :)
musicdao-demo-video-v4.mp4
Summary of updates to Thesis Report
synctext commentedon Feb 11, 2021
Tim-W commentedon Feb 15, 2021
I got a second bootstrap server succesfully running thanks to Sandip.
synctext commentedon Feb 16, 2021
Nice!, please push speed (initial music discovery) and robustness (bootstraping) improvements to Android store.
today if you can.
Tim-W commentedon Feb 20, 2021
Updates week 1 of writing
Problem of centralization/platformization on the Internet > What is a robot economy (theory) -> What is a robot economy in software? -> What does it achieve (key characteristics) -> Problem of centralization in music industry -> Our first steps towards robot economy: MusicDAO
In other news: Effect of TorrentFreak publication first day

Updates week 2 of writing
MSc_Thesis_25-02-2021.pdf
synctext commentedon Feb 25, 2021
52 pages π quick remarks, that robot economy architecture picture is great! Please make this the centerpiece of your solution and final thesis presentation. This is the future of the firm! Spend a few hours to make it stand-out if possible:
Tim-W commentedon Feb 25, 2021
More updates week 2 of writing
Received first feedback from Georgy Tim-W/msc-thesis#1 - he is working on more feedback
MSc-Thesis-26-02-2021.pdf
synctext commentedon Feb 26, 2021
to its users?" or 'How can we design and implement a music streaming service that prevents natural monopolies and transfers all power to Internet users?' ref
Tim-W commentedon Mar 9, 2021
Updates to report and evaluation/experimentation
Improved test coverage, add LOC to table. Most non-ui code is covered with Unit tests
Updates to Evaluation (re-done some experiments, updated some analysis
Re-done n=10 content discovery experiment as the previous run suffered from network congestion
Re-done search latency experiment, now timed without UI rendering time
Improved analysis: BTC Faucet Responsiveness experiment throughout a full month (d=28)
Please note, app activations are here also recorded **outside of google play**, so also local test devices are incorporated in the data (the data is from Crashlytics _first_open_ event).The lines should overlap. Reasons for no overlapping can be:
which only use other mini-apps inside trustchain superapp (opened the app, but never opened MusicDAO)
Improved analysis of artist income vs. Google Play installs:
Clarified experiment: phone-to-phone vs. central server+phones topology
Abstract (draft)
During the last decades of explosive growth in economic value on the Internet, we observe the trend of platformization: a shift of economic activity from happening on a wide range of companies to a few major platforms run by Big Tech corporations. This trend is highly susceptible to the rise of monopolies and oligarchs, as seen in the music industry today. In this industry, the top 5 streaming services and top 3 labels form oligarchs. Artist income is diminishing because these powerful intermediaries take large revenue cuts. Streaming services also have curatorial power: they decide the inner workings of their black box recommendation systems. As an alternative for centralized Internet platforms, this thesis presents a theoretical framework for building a robot economy in software: autonomous software in which robots perform monetary transactions on their own. It allows for building infrastructure for the common good: software systems that (1) handle financial transactions in a fair way, as (2) decided by democratic engagement, (3) run transparently and autonomously, (4) are open to any participant (permissionless), (5) are decentralized and leaderless, (6) support a self-evolving codebase, and finally (7) can make intelligent decisions on their own using AI. We show a proof-of-concept of this framework, by implementing features 1,3,4 and 5. We present a fully operational decentralized music streaming, publishing and discovery mobile app (called MusicDAO) with peer-to-peer donations to artists. It is built on a fully distributed, self-scaling network of Android phones. The app was released to the public, and was installed on 50+ devices. During this public trial, the decentral financial infrastructure was successful: most music streaming platforms take a 20-40% cut of music revenue; MusicDAO takes <0.001%. Discovery and metadata search is operational with low latency. Peer-to-peer music streaming is operational, but its latency is not yet competitive. Our framework and proof-of-concept are fruitful steps towards research into infrastructure for the common good: software systems that are governed by its users instead of by profit-driven corporations.
New version of MSc thesis:
Update march 12: proofread everything, many small updates throughout entire thesis to make it a better flow/storyline.
Update march 13: Improved robot eco diagram, Re-made fig. 1.2 with consistent style. Added consistent style for all the diagrams I made. Replaced package diagram with a more simplified component diagram (5.1). Improved architecture diagram in Design. Improved conclusion. Added abstract and preface. Improved introduction. Improved conclusion.
Update march 14: Improved explanation of our robot economy framework in 1.2
https://github.com/Tim-W/msc-thesis/blob/master/report.pdf
Merge pull request Tribler#45 from rwblokzijl/master