Skip to content

UX: Settings / About button is confusing as a tab toggleΒ #2492

Open

Description

@fain182

Currently, the "Settings / About" button in the bottom-left sidebar hides the main tab bar (Repository, Sources, Schedule, Archives) and replaces it with the Settings/About tabs. To return to the main view, the user must click the same button again β€” or click the current profile in the sidebar.

This pattern has a few issues:

  • It's not obvious the button is a toggle
  • The main tab bar disappearing without a clear "back" affordance is disorienting
  • With a single profile, clicking the profile to go back is not discoverable

This was actually noted during the review of #1809, where @m3nu wrote:

"Goal is basically to make closing the Settings view more intuitive"

A few workarounds were added at the time (bold font on the active button, clicking the current profile to return), but the underlying pattern remains confusing.

Proposed solution

Open Settings / About in a modal dialog (e.g. QDialog), keeping the main window and its tabs always visible in the background. This is the standard pattern on both macOS and Linux desktop apps, and matches what was originally sketched in #1677.

The change would be scoped to:

  • A new SettingsDialog wrapping the existing MiscTab and AboutTab (which stay mostly unchanged)
  • Updating toggle_misc_visibility() in main_window.py to open the dialog instead
  • Removing miscWidget from the main window layout

Additional improvement

As a follow-up, Settings and About could be split into two separate buttons with dedicated dialogs. They serve different purposes β€” one is operational, the other purely informational β€” and this matches the common desktop convention of a dedicated "About AppName" dialog.

Happy to work on a PR if the direction makes sense.

Activity

  1. rzeigler commented on Oct 27, 2026

    @rzeigler
    Contributor

    What if Settings and About were simply 2 more tabs on the main bar?

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    type:enhancementImprovement of an existing function

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions