| Sezona |
Polufinale (1. utakmica) |
Polufinale (2. utakmica) |
Finale |
| 2004./05. |
Lincoln City 1:0 Macclesfield Town
Northampton Town 0:0 Southend United |
Macclesfield Town 1:1 Lincoln City
Southend United 1:0 Northampton Town |
Lincoln City 0:2 Southend United |
| 2005./06. |
Lincoln City 0:1 Grimsby Town
Wycombe Wanderers 1:2 Cheltenham Town |
Grimsby Town 2:1 Lincoln City
Cheltenham Town 0:0 Wycombe Wanderers |
Grimsby Town 0:1 Cheltenham Town |
| 2006./07. |
Bristol Rovers 2:1 Lincoln City
Shrewsbury Town 0:0 Milton Keynes Dons |
Lincoln City 3:5 Bristol Rovers
Milton Keynes Dons 1:2 Shrewsbury Town |
Bristol Rovers 3:1 Shrewsbury Town |
| 2007./08. |
Darlington 2:1 Rochdale
Wycombe Wanderers 1:1 Stockport County |
Rochdale 2:1 Darlington
(Rochdale je pobijedio 5:4 nakon izvođenja jedanaesteraca) Stockport County 1:0 Wycombe Wanderers |
Rochdale 2:3 Stockport County |
| 2008./09. |
Shrewsbury Town 0:1 Bury
Rochdale 0:0 Gillingham |
Bury 0:1 Shrewsbury Town
(Shrewsbury je pobijedio 4:3 nakon izvođenja jedanaesteraca) Gillingham 2:1 Rochdale |
Gillingham 1:0 Shrewsbury Town |
| 2009./10. |
Dagenham & Redbridge 6:0 Morecambe
Aldershot Town 0:1 Rotherham United |
Morecambe 2:1 Dagenham & Redbridge
Rotherham United 2:0 Aldershot Town |
Dagenham & Redbridge 3:2 Rotherham United |
| 2010./11. |
Torquay United 2:0 Shrewsbury Town
Stevenage 2:0 Accrington Stanley |
Shrewsbury Town 0:0 Torquay United
Accrington Stanley 0:1 Stevenage |
Stevenage 1:0 Torquay United |
| 2011./12. |
Crewe Alexandra 1:0 Southend United
Cheltenham Town 2:0 Torquay United |
Southend United 2:2 Crewe Alexandra
Torquay United 1:2 Cheltenham Town |
Cheltenham Town 0:2 Crewe Alexandra |
| 2012./13. |
Bradford City 2:3 Burton Albion
Northampton Town 1:0 Cheltenham Town |
Burton Albion 1:3 Bradford City
Cheltenham Town 0:1 Northampton Town |
Bradford City 3:0 Northampton Town |
| 2013./14. |
Burton Albion 1:0 Southend United
York City 0:1 Fleetwood Town |
Southend United 2:2 Burton Albion
Fleetwood Town 0:0 York City |
Burton Albion 0:1 Fleetwood Town |
| 2014./15. |
Stevenage 1:1 Southend United
Plymouth Argyle 2:3 Wycombe Wanderers |
Southend United 3:1 Stevenage
(nakon produžetaka) Wycombe Wanderers 2:1 Plymouth Argyle |
Southend United 1:1 Wycombe Wanderers
(Southend je pobijedio 7:6 nakon izvođenja jedanaesteraca) |
| 2015./16. |
Portsmouth 2:2 Plymouth Argyle
AFC Wimbledon 1:0 Accrington Stanley |
Plymouth Argyle 1:0 Portsmouth
Accrington Stanley 2:2 AFC Wimbledon (nakon produžetaka) |
AFC Wimbledon 2:0 Plymouth Argyle |
| 2016./17. |
Blackpool 3:2 Luton Town
Carlisle United 3:3 Exeter City |
Luton Town 3:3 Blackpool
Exeter City 3:2 Carlisle United |
Blackpool 2:1 Exeter City |
| 2017./18. |
Lincoln City 0:0 Exeter City
Coventry City 1:1 Notts County |
Exeter City 3:1 Lincoln City
Notts County 1:4 Coventry City |
Coventry City 3:1 Exeter City |
| 2018./19. |
Newport County 1:1 Mansfield Town
Tranmere Rovers 1:0 Forest Green Rovers |
Mansfield Town 0:0 Newport County
(Newport je pobijedio 5:3 nakon izvođenja jedanaesteraca) Forest Green Rovers 1:1 Tranmere Rovers |
Newport County 0:1 Tranmere Rovers
(nakon produžetaka) |
| 2019./20. |
Colchester United 1:0 Exeter City
Northampton Town 0:2 Cheltenham Town |
Exeter City 3:1 Colchester United
Cheltenham Town 0:3 Northampton Town |
Exeter City 0:4 Northampton Town |
| 2020./21. |
Newport County 2:0 Forest Green Rovers
Tranmere Rovers 1:2 Morecambe |
Forest Green Rovers 4:3 Newport County (nakon produžetaka)
Morecambe 1:1 Tranmere Rovers |
Morecambe 1:0 Newport County |
| 2021./22. |
Mansfield Town 2:1 Northampton Town
Swindon Town 2:1 Port Vale |
Northampton Town 0:1 Mansfield Town
Port Vale 1:1 Swindon Town (Port Vale je pobijedio 6:5 nakon izvođenja jedanaesteraca) |
Mansfield Town 0:3 Port Vale |
| 2022./23. |
Salford City 1:0 Stockport County
Bradford City 1:0 Carlisle United |
Stockport County 2:1 Salford City
(Stockport County je pobijedio 3:1 nakon izvođenja jedanaesteraca) Carlisle United 3:1 (nakon produžetaka) Bradford City |
Stockport County 1:1 Carlisle United
(Carlisle je pobijedio 5:4 nakon izvođenja jedanaesteraca) |
| 2023./24. |
Crawley Town 3:0 Milton Keynes Dons
Crewe Alexandra 0:2 Doncaster Rovers |
Milton Keynes Dons 1:5 Crawley Town
Doncaster Rovers 0:2 Crewe Alexandra (Crewe Alexandra je pobjedila 4:3 nakon izvođenja jedanaesteraca) |
Crawley Town 2:0 Crewe Alexandra |
| 2024./25. |
Notts County 0:1 AFC Wimbledon
Chesterfield 0:2 Walsall |
AFC Wimbledon 1:0 Notts County
Walsall 2:1 Chesterfield |
AFC Wimbledon 1:0 Walsall |