Life is Strangeā„¢

Life is Strangeā„¢

View Stats:
Very poor ending??? (Spoiler)
A big problem with the sacrifice Arcadia Bay ending Chloe is not the only person Max has strong feelings for. Kate, Joyce and Warren are people Max also cares about deeply, with Kate being a very important part of the story and someone who becomes a very close friend to Max, Joyce basically being a second mother to Max and Warren becoming as much as a romantic partner depending on the player's choices involving him. Max also grew up in Arcadia Bay and often shows she has feelings for the town itself.
just like how Chloe mentioned on how selfish she would be if everyone died for her, Isn’t it very selfish to straight up kill everyone who you love just to save Chloe?
< >
Showing 1-15 of 172 comments
It is. Most people I saw that argued sacrificing Chloe is the wrong choice weren't even hiding about how they don't value eveyone else's lives and said Max shouldn't too.

:summercat2023:
Most people would have done the same thing to save their loved one. If most people are selfish too, then why should you be the one to sacrifice your loved one for selfish people? Is that being selfish, or being conscious?

If saving Chloe is selfish, then why did the universe give Max her powers to save her?

Who decides that some young girl's life is worth less than that of some random people in a random town? Isn't a heartbroken girl's death still a tragedy? Does it have to be a mass death to count as a tragedy?

Yes maybe it's a selfish act but it's an understandable one, one that's born out of love
Originally posted by Bilge:
Most people would have done the same thing to save their loved one. If most people are selfish too, then why should you be the one to sacrifice your loved one for selfish people? Is that being selfish, or being conscious?

If saving Chloe is selfish, then why did the universe give Max her powers to save her?

Who decides that some young girl's life is worth less than that of some random people in a random town? Isn't a heartbroken girl's death still a tragedy? Does it have to be a mass death to count as a tragedy?

Yes maybe it's a selfish act but it's an understandable one, one that's born out of love
But Max was on good terms with people from the bay, she grew up there and yearns for it, chloes mom was like a second mother to her plus all of her friends, I believe she got these powers to spend more time with chloe before her time comes. And Chloe wasn’t even a good person, she was a trouble maker and dragged Max with her all the way, and she’s so unappreciative for everything her mom sacrificed for her.
Chloe is not a bad person at all, she's just a mess
Originally posted by Bilge:
Most people would have done the same thing to save their loved one. If most people are selfish too, then why should you be the one to sacrifice your loved one for selfish people? Is that being selfish, or being conscious?
Only a psychopath would genocide an entire town to fulfill their selfish desires. You're basically gaslighting most people to be a psychopath to justify another psychopath massacring them and the innocent people who happened to live at the same town.
If saving Chloe is selfish, then why did the universe give Max her powers to save her?
The universe gave her powers to go back and undo her actions saving her. The universe didn't tell her to save Chloe, Max did it on her own.
Who decides that some young girl's life is worth less than that of some random people in a random town?
And who decides the lives of people in a town is worth less than a random girl? Like I said, Chloe defenders doesn't value anyone else's s lives.
Isn't a heartbroken girl's death still a tragedy? Does it have to be a mass death to count as a tragedy?
Wow, you're going full Stalin with this "death of one is a tragedy, death of a million is a statistic" mindset. Her death is tragic, but knowingly murder an entire town from your own action is just as tragic, if not more.

Nothing wrong to save one person over a million, it's like Spiderman saving MJ alone in the first movie when the villain gives him a choice to either save her or a cable car full of children, i don't blame spider for going for MJ first. The difference is however, you are responsible for the mass people's death and the death of Chloe wasn't your fault so it's kinda scummy when you unintentionally causing thousands of people to die to save 1 person, and when you're aware they are dying because of you, you decided to "meh screw them, im still gonna rescue this 1 person".


Originally posted by Bilge:
Chloe is not a bad person at all, she's just a mess
She sucks weed, drink till she's drunk, stole a gun and lied about it, stole money for the children, ungratefully guilt trips Max when things doesn't go her way, decided to kill Nathan for falsely believing he killed Amber, puts the blame on Max when David discovered her grass in her room, etc.

To be fair, there some nice things she did like taking the effort to print and put posters of Amber when she went missing and gifting Max her father's camera, but you can't deny all the bad things that she's done are suffice for people to say she's bad.
Originally posted by Cat:
Originally posted by Bilge:
If saving Chloe is selfish, then why did the universe give Max her powers to save her?
The universe gave her powers to go back and undo her actions saving her. The universe didn't tell her to save Chloe, Max did it on her own.
Max saved Chloe on her own, using the powers. If there was any intent behind the powers, it seems unlikely that it was "let things play out exactly the way they would have without the powers" which is the Sacrifice Chloe ending.
Originally posted by Cat:
Originally posted by Bilge:
Chloe is not a bad person at all, she's just a mess
She [...] decided to kill Nathan for falsely believing he killed Amber
The evidence is that Nathan killed Rachel by giving her an overdose of sedative. Not sure why you're labelling that as a false belief.

As for the choice itself, there are at least three reasonable framings of it, depending on how far into character you get:

- If you know what both endings will be, which one should a reasonable person choose?

- Based on what Max knows at the time of making the decision, which one should a reasonable person choose?

- Which would Max choose?

In the first framing, it's hard to argue that Sacrifice Arcadia Bay is a reasonable decision. The best I can think of is that, having taken action to prevent someone's death, discovering that a consequence of that is the death of thousands does not oblige you to take definite action to knowingly cause the first person's death after all. This is still the dilemma at the heart of the trolley problem - is it right to knowingly murder someone in order to save multiple other lives? And if so, why does involuntary organ donation seem wrong? Pick a random 30-year-old and chop them up for spare parts, and you'll extend the recipients' lives by more than the victim lost...

In the second framing, the argument for Sacrificing Chloe is the argument that the way to prevent/undo a storm that was already predicted before Chloe's death, and which has been getting worse the more Max tries to change time around, is to change time around yet again, and let Chloe be killed, because surely this time messing with time will make things better rather than worse... It's like the gambler who's been on a losing streak deciding to double-down and make a bet big enough to cover all their losses rather than learning the lesson and walking away while they still have something to spend.

The third framing is pretty subjective, and, while it can justify a player's decision to pick one over the other, is irrelevant to the question of whether Max is right to make either choice.
Originally posted by Cat:
Originally posted by Bilge:
Most people would have done the same thing to save their loved one. If most people are selfish too, then why should you be the one to sacrifice your loved one for selfish people? Is that being selfish, or being conscious?
Only a psychopath would genocide an entire town to fulfill their selfish desires. You're basically gaslighting most people to be a psychopath to justify another psychopath massacring them and the innocent people who happened to live at the same town.
If saving Chloe is selfish, then why did the universe give Max her powers to save her?
The universe gave her powers to go back and undo her actions saving her. The universe didn't tell her to save Chloe, Max did it on her own.
Who decides that some young girl's life is worth less than that of some random people in a random town?
And who decides the lives of people in a town is worth less than a random girl? Like I said, Chloe defenders doesn't value anyone else's s lives.
Isn't a heartbroken girl's death still a tragedy? Does it have to be a mass death to count as a tragedy?
Wow, you're going full Stalin with this "death of one is a tragedy, death of a million is a statistic" mindset. Her death is tragic, but knowingly murder an entire town from your own action is just as tragic, if not more.

Nothing wrong to save one person over a million, it's like Spiderman saving MJ alone in the first movie when the villain gives him a choice to either save her or a cable car full of children, i don't blame spider for going for MJ first. The difference is however, you are responsible for the mass people's death and the death of Chloe wasn't your fault so it's kinda scummy when you unintentionally causing thousands of people to die to save 1 person, and when you're aware they are dying because of you, you decided to "meh screw them, im still gonna rescue this 1 person".


Originally posted by Bilge:
Chloe is not a bad person at all, she's just a mess
She sucks weed, drink till she's drunk, stole a gun and lied about it, stole money for the children, ungratefully guilt trips Max when things doesn't go her way, decided to kill Nathan for falsely believing he killed Amber, puts the blame on Max when David discovered her grass in her room, etc.

To be fair, there some nice things she did like taking the effort to print and put posters of Amber when she went missing and gifting Max her father's camera, but you can't deny all the bad things that she's done are suffice for people to say she's bad.


Genocide? Wow, that's not even close to the genocide. Genocide is act of systematically killing certain kind of people who are seen as inferior. This is not genocide at all, not even close, maybe it's selfish but it's understandable. Chloe doesn't have to sacrifice herself for anybody

In the bathroom, she suddenly has powers, right in the heat of the moment, to save her. If you were right, then the universe would have given her powers at a different moment

Again as I said, most people would have done the same. Why would I choose a town of 'innocent' people when most of them would do the same thing? No I'm not gaslighting anybody, If you think most people would sacrifice somebody they love, you're living in a fantasy world

She sometimes smokes weed to relax, it doesn't mean she's a bad person

She never got drunk in the game, we have only seen her drinking beer once.

She stole bribe money,

She didn't guilt trip Max, show me one example.

She didn't plan to kill Nathan either. Planning is a long process. She found out Nathan overdosed and killed Rachel, and she got furious that's it.

She did put the blame on Max because David was being mean to her, and Max is her childhood friend. It's not like she was falsely accusing some random person just to get away with a charge or anything.

The only 'bad' thing Chloe did was steal her stepfather's gun because she feared for her life after being threatened and drugged by Nathan
It is unbelievable what emotional thinking can do to you and how blind emotional thinking can make you, and also how far such people will go to justify their insane actions.
@Suffocation

You are right, but there is no point in trying to (re~)explain it to those incapable of seeing it.
Originally posted by Ayleen:
@Suffocation

You are right, but there is no point in trying to (re~)explain it to those incapable of seeing it.

Lol, why should I sacrifice someone I love in a situation like this? Society in general is selfish itself, so why should I bother? It's not about being incapable of seeing; on the contrary, it's about being conscious of the fact that being altruistic in a selfish society makes you nothing more than a foolish slave
Originally posted by Cat:
That was beautifully said @Cat, personally I think the only right ending is either she sacrifice Chloe or herself and take that bullet. Max has always been selfless and willing to take the extra effort for the people around her but killing the whole town is just crazy what were the devs thinking. I know they wanna keep the protagonist alive but we only got that filler game that has nothing to do with the actual Max.
I feel like, you know, the whole point is that you have to make one final choice.

At first, Max wasn't even responsible for Chloe's death by Nathan, but by using the rewind and actively choosing to do nothing, she becomes responsible, after spending days getting to know each other again, which is all part of what makes it so hard. After all, at first, Max doesn't even recognise Chloe, and you will probably have to try at least twice to stop the struggle when you're first playing.

Through the whole game you've got choices to make, many of them hard choices. And often, regardless of your choice, Max feels like she's made the wrong choice. Whether you take the blame for the weed, or let Chloe take responsibility, Max will still feel bad, and there will be both good and bad consequences for both.

So at the end, you've got that last choice and you will never be able to rewind it. It's your best friend, or the whole town. It's not meant to be an easy choice for a kid. Whatever she decides, she's fully responsible. What would you really do, if you really did have to make that killer choice?

The only thing that makes it bearable, is Chloe realising that she's been a complete doom magnet this whole time and that if you didn't let her die, even more destruction would surely follow her.

I don't think Chloe's meant to be a bad person at heart. But she's gone through a lot of changes in the time she and Max were apart. She's not the awesome friend Max sometimes thinks of her as. She's so needy and clingy. She treats Max's superpower like a toy. She asks you to steal money and throws a baby-tantrum when you don't. Hell, the AU Chloe will guilt-trip you if you don't kill her!
Originally posted by Bilge:
Genocide? Wow, that's not even close to the genocide. Genocide is act of systematically killing certain kind of people who are seen as inferior.
Which is exactly why I used the word genocide.
In the bathroom, she suddenly has powers, right in the heat of the moment, to save her. If you were right, then the universe would have given her powers at a different moment
Okay, it's the writers who decided to give her the powers at that moment because the plot needed to happen. Not some sentient universe being thinks she should have superpowers.

Originally posted by Bilge:

Why would I choose a town of 'innocent' people when most of them would do the same thing?
Because not everyone is a chloe shipper who doesn't value thousands of lives and is selfishly gonna mass murder them all.
No I'm not gaslighting anybody, If you think most people would sacrifice somebody they love, you're living in a fantasy world
Well, you're gaslighting us into thinking we are bad people for sacrificing Chloe to save thousands of innocent lives and everyone else is selfish.
She didn't guilt trip Max, show me one example.
Pick a choice that doesn't favor Chloe and see her reaction. Off course, chloe fans would never do that so that's why they were never aware of her guilt tripping attitude.
She did put the blame on Max because David was being mean to her, and Max is her childhood friend. It's not like she was falsely accusing some random person just to get away with a charge or anything.
Yeah, blaming your own childhood friend who just get to reunite with you and one of the first things you do is blame her for the weed that could affect her grades in school when David is clearly being mean. Some friend chloe is. Not sure chloe fans realize this or not, but that explanation from you kinda made her look even worse and proves my point about her.



Originally posted by Suffocation:
Originally posted by Cat:
That was beautifully said @Cat, personally I think the only right ending is either she sacrifice Chloe or herself and take that bullet. Max has always been selfless and willing to take the extra effort for the people around her but killing the whole town is just crazy what were the devs thinking. I know they wanna keep the protagonist alive but we only got that filler game that has nothing to do with the actual Max.
Yup, Chloe was willing to let Max sacrifice her, and Max was the more selfless person of the 2 so it's kinda more fitting for her.
>Which is exactly why I used the word genocide.

So you admit that you don't know what genocide means? Great that's an improvement

>Okay, it's the writers who decided to give her the powers at that moment because the plot needed to happen. Not some sentient universe being thinks she should have superpowers.

Yeah but you can make the plot happen in very different ways, it's not like their only choice. So my point is still valid, it implies that Chloe should be saved

>Because not everyone is a chloe shipper who doesn't value thousands of lives and is selfishly gonna mass murder them all.

Why do I need to value thousands of lives? Like I said, most people are selfish, so why should I have to sacrifice someone I love in a situation where most people would sacrifice the town? This isn’t gaslighting or anything like that, so please stop repeating that like a parrot. If you’re being altruistic for people who don’t deserve it, man, you’re being a brainwashed slave, nothing more.

Sure, maybe there were some 'good' people who would have sacrificed somebody they love but that's just because they hadn’t experienced enough to see themselves become the villain. Sorry, these are the facts.


>Well, you're gaslighting us into thinking we are bad people for sacrificing Chloe to save thousands of innocent lives and everyone else is selfish.

Umm, no I never said or implied that if you sacrifice Chloe you are a bad person or selfish or anything like that, where did that come from?

>Pick a choice that doesn't favor Chloe and see her reaction. Off course, chloe fans would never do that so that's why they were never aware of her guilt tripping attitude.

Hmm, really? For example, if you answer Kate's phone just before you leave the diner with Chloe, she’ll be pissed off because she’s the most toxic douchebag ever, right? Let’s change our perspective for a second. Let’s say you’ve been feeling completely alone for a long time, your best friend disappeared, and deep down, you probably know she’s been murdered. On top of that, you have deep traumas and things like that, no big deal, right? But then, suddenly, your childhood friend comes to town after ignoring you for years. You don't care about all that, after all, she’s your best childhood friend. You and her are in a diner, just before you leave, her phone rings. Just because you want to spend time with your childhood friend, you don’t want her to answer the phone. But she goes ahead and answers the phone from somebody she sees every day at school, after not calling you for five years. Wow, you must be a pos for pointing out the obvious, not to mention you say sorry after finding out what she’s been going through. But hey, you must be faking it, right? Because you’re a selfish douchebag who guilt trips people for fun

>Yeah, blaming your own childhood friend who just get to reunite with you and one of the first things you do is blame her for the weed that could affect her grades in school when David is clearly being mean. Some friend chloe is. Not sure chloe fans realize this or not, but that explanation from you kinda made her look even worse and proves my point about her.

How on earth smoking weed outside the school borders could affect your grades? He's not even a teacher, lol. Let's say it somehow affects your grades, cool. Do you really think that Chloe planned in her head that if she put the blame on Max she could get low grades? Or she put the blame on her just because she didn't want to get slapped and attract more attention from David?
i mean prior to the decisions you had to or could save many people.
so why would i just say ♄♄♄♄ those people and save chloe?
< >
Showing 1-15 of 172 comments
Per page: 1530 50