Life is Strange™

Life is Strange™

View Stats:
2015 vs. 2024
What did the original Life is Strange do right to make it so good?

Looking at the ♥♥♥♥ with DE, it's hard to believe how massively the franchise has declined. Arcadia Bay was believable and vibrant, even without good graphics. Or maybe because of that? And the emotions it evoked were something few other games had managed to do before.

DE, on the other hand, feels dead. Unbelievable, boring, and poorly put together.
It's an incredible shame.

Opinions?
< >
Showing 1-4 of 4 comments
The first LiS game was a lightning in bottle.

In my opinion, it ain't a perfect game. Hell, from a critical standpoint, it ain't even in my top 10.

But despite not being "the best", the emotional impact the left behind with me is so huge that I can confidently say it marked a turning point in my years in gaming. It didn't need to have the best characters, the best graphics, the best lines, etc to strike a chord with me all this time.

As to what it did right, well, that would depend on whom you ask.

Personally, I felt like it was a perfect storm several elements that all combined together to form one impactful game. The chemistry between Max and Chloe being a major highlight, of course. The music was beautiful, and introduced me to a world of indie artists I wouldn't have easily found if it was just up to the mercy of random internet algorithms. The game was evocative of films such as The Breakfast Club, mixed in with the likes of Donnie Darko... which made the game all the more gripping. The cinematography was of a dreamy, nostalgic vibe. The game's overall tone was great, which was well said in a comment I found years ago:

Arcadia Bay was a fantasy frontier town, a modern Wild West setting with its own shadowy government (the Prescotts), the corrupt cops, the freaking Hogwarts-Blackwell, etc. Seattle was this mystical place friends disappeared to, never to be heard from again. San Francisco was an art gallery you had to travel to by plane. There was no Obama, 9/11, 2008 recession, Sandy Hook, or Bin Laden getting whacked.

Also, all five episodes of LiS 1 were written by Christian Divine... who seems to have left Dontnod after LiS 2.
Originally posted by Marshall of the Templars:
The first LiS game was a lightning in bottle.

In my opinion, it ain't a perfect game. Hell, from a critical standpoint, it ain't even in my top 10.

But despite not being "the best", the emotional impact the left behind with me is so huge that I can confidently say it marked a turning point in my years in gaming. It didn't need to have the best characters, the best graphics, the best lines, etc to strike a chord with me all this time.

As to what it did right, well, that would depend on whom you ask.

Personally, I felt like it was a perfect storm several elements that all combined together to form one impactful game. The chemistry between Max and Chloe being a major highlight, of course. The music was beautiful, and introduced me to a world of indie artists I wouldn't have easily found if it was just up to the mercy of random internet algorithms. The game was evocative of films such as The Breakfast Club, mixed in with the likes of Donnie Darko... which made the game all the more gripping. The cinematography was of a dreamy, nostalgic vibe. The game's overall tone was great, which was well said in a comment I found years ago:

Arcadia Bay was a fantasy frontier town, a modern Wild West setting with its own shadowy government (the Prescotts), the corrupt cops, the freaking Hogwarts-Blackwell, etc. Seattle was this mystical place friends disappeared to, never to be heard from again. San Francisco was an art gallery you had to travel to by plane. There was no Obama, 9/11, 2008 recession, Sandy Hook, or Bin Laden getting whacked.

Also, all five episodes of LiS 1 were written by Christian Divine... who seems to have left Dontnod after LiS 2.

No LiS is in no way perfect and I don't think it intends to be!

But this game, is just next level. It's as if they try to punish players for their decitions in the first game. Wtf?! DeckNine seemed to outright disrespect the original game throughout Double Exposure. What baffles me is how this game chooses to intentionally upset its core fanbase. They brought back Max Caulfield, which is fan service, but they seem to disrespect the source material in every way, making this game less appealing to original fans.

Either they do not understand why the first game was such a huge thing and so loved, or they just don't care. DE was very expensive and I don't think that there is one thing to blame alone. The whole production process was trash from the start.

Why did they upset a huge number of their fans, literally earsing all means of the first game with two really badly wirtten explanations? Do they want to separate from the original fanbase and start a new one with Double Exposure?

I thought my biggest problem would be the complete assassination of Pricefield — and I’m talking both as a romantic relationship and friendship (I did friendship). They just reduced Chloe (the focal point of the first game, whether you like it or not) to a couple of weird online posts, and overall threw the whole plot of the original game out of the window.
You can say and think what you want about Pricefield - but this lack of respect tells you everything you need to know. At this point I would have respected them more if they’d just came out and said it outright: saving Arcadia Bay is canon and there is no possibility to make it otherwise in this game.

But this is far from being the main problem, however. The main problem is the crippled, mind numbingly stupid narrative along with characters that are supposed to look and act like people, but feel more like puppets put there for plot purposes. Frankly though, using the word “plot” for whatever cursed piece of nonsensical garbage this game was, is quite generous. You are just randomly presented with this new place, new characters — here they are, look, how and why they got where they are and, most importantly, who they are? Ah, you will figure it out as you go! Or you won’t.

None of the characters have any sort of clear occupation status, neither it is ever explained why in the world would Max would be friends with them. How did she end up in this town, in this college, how did they become friends with Safi, who, for the love of god, Safi even is? Or better, who is Max?
Originally posted by Marshall of the Templars:
The first LiS game was a lightning in bottle.

In my opinion, it ain't a perfect game. Hell, from a critical standpoint, it ain't even in my top 10.

But despite not being "the best", the emotional impact the left behind with me is so huge that I can confidently say it marked a turning point in my years in gaming. It didn't need to have the best characters, the best graphics, the best lines, etc to strike a chord with me all this time.

As to what it did right, well, that would depend on whom you ask.

Personally, I felt like it was a perfect storm several elements that all combined together to form one impactful game. The chemistry between Max and Chloe being a major highlight, of course. The music was beautiful, and introduced me to a world of indie artists I wouldn't have easily found if it was just up to the mercy of random internet algorithms. The game was evocative of films such as The Breakfast Club, mixed in with the likes of Donnie Darko... which made the game all the more gripping. The cinematography was of a dreamy, nostalgic vibe. The game's overall tone was great, which was well said in a comment I found years ago:

Arcadia Bay was a fantasy frontier town, a modern Wild West setting with its own shadowy government (the Prescotts), the corrupt cops, the freaking Hogwarts-Blackwell, etc. Seattle was this mystical place friends disappeared to, never to be heard from again. San Francisco was an art gallery you had to travel to by plane. There was no Obama, 9/11, 2008 recession, Sandy Hook, or Bin Laden getting whacked.

Also, all five episodes of LiS 1 were written by Christian Divine... who seems to have left Dontnod after LiS 2.
I have to agree with this one about being a lightning in a bottle.
The first game was a success because the devs knew what they were doing, the writer wanted to make a good story and present it as a story rich choice matters game. Haven't completed playing LiS2 yet but I heard it was decent. They said it themselves the game story has ended and they're okay with it.

The later titles feel like they are milking the franchise first. Bringing Max back is a lazy attempt to get longtime fans to buy it, story is lazy and uninspiring. Maybe I would be more generous if they used original characters even if the story/gameplay sucks because at least it looks like they were trying but using Max just screams desperation at trying to get people playing it, or worse, deliberately trying to piss off fans. Max said she doesn't wanna use her powers again and now you're giving her new powers?

Even if they wanna bring back Max, which I'm not a fan of, it could still work if they treat the character, her story arc and sacrifice, the original devs story and most importantly the fans with respect.
< >
Showing 1-4 of 4 comments
Per page: 1530 50