Life is Strangeā„¢

Life is Strangeā„¢

View Stats:
It doesn’t really make sense to save the town
Calm down, it’s just my opinion and I’ll explain why.

If you save the town, you go back in time and let Chloe die, which means you lose all the progress you made throughout the game. On top of that, Chloe’s mom, who already lost her husband, would now lose her daughter too, which is devastating. I’m pretty sure that if Joyce had to choose between her own life or her daughter’s, she’d choose Chloe without thinking twice. So her death ends up being for a good reason. And if you’re worried about Chloe, understand that this is the natural order of things, parents die, and sooner or later, a child will lose their parents. But parents losing their children? That’s not natural, and in my opinion, one of the worst things someone can go through.

Also, as shown in Life is Strange 2, David takes the blame for Chloe’s death and ends up in a really bad place because of it. But if you save Chloe, he makes peace with her and they actually build a decent relationship. She even sends him photos with Max and everything. Basically, by saving the town, every important character we care about ends up miserable, and you also lose all the relationship progress you built. And honestly, saving the people in the town who mostly treated you like crap doesn’t feel like a good enough reason.

Another point is: why do you even have powers in the first place? Why would you suddenly get these powers (which were triggered to SAVE Chloe) just to decide to go back and undo everything? You had the vision of the storm before even using your powers, and the first time you used them was to save Chloe. If the whole point was to just let her die, the game wouldn't even need half of its story.

I get that morally it might be the ā€œrightā€ choice, but for me, saving Chloe makes way more sense within the narrative.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 19 comments
For me, the biggest problem with sacrificing Chloe is that, based on what we're shown beforehand, it shouldn't work - Max was seeing visions of the coming storm even in the original timeline where Chloe does die, and then we're shown things getting worse the more Max uses her powers.

And yet we're supposed to accept that, after attempts to fix things using time travel have repeatedly failed, this time using time travel to try to fix things will not only stop making things worse, but will also retcon away the storm?

Also, if one takes sacrificing Chloe to be the correct choice, that gives the game a bad unintended message - that if you see something bad happening, you should just ignore it and not get involved. Max intervenes to prevent a murder, and (according to this view) you get the "bad" ending; Max deliberately lets someone be murdered in front of her, and (again, according to this view) you get the "good" ending...
Originally posted by rmsgrey:
For me, the biggest problem with sacrificing Chloe is that, based on what we're shown beforehand, it shouldn't work - Max was seeing visions of the coming storm even in the original timeline where Chloe does die, and then we're shown things getting worse the more Max uses her powers.

And yet we're supposed to accept that, after attempts to fix things using time travel have repeatedly failed, this time using time travel to try to fix things will not only stop making things worse, but will also retcon away the storm?

Also, if one takes sacrificing Chloe to be the correct choice, that gives the game a bad unintended message - that if you see something bad happening, you should just ignore it and not get involved. Max intervenes to prevent a murder, and (according to this view) you get the "bad" ending; Max deliberately lets someone be murdered in front of her, and (again, according to this view) you get the "good" ending...
Exactly. We had the vision before using our powers.

I also think it doesn’t make much sense. If the more we use them, the worse things get, then if we only use them to save Chloe and nothing else, shouldn’t everything be fine? And how does using them AGAIN, but this time to let Chloe die, suddenly fix everything?

And like you said, what kind of message does it send that simply letting her die is the ā€œgood endingā€? I believe we got these powers for a reason, and that reason would be to do the right thing. It doesn’t make sense that we’d be punished for trying to save everyone, INCLUDING Chloe…
Having the vision before using her powers is just foreshadowing of the story. It doesn't mean the storm would not have happened had Max done nothing.
Originally posted by Jack-alope:
Having the vision before using her powers is just foreshadowing of the story. It doesn't mean the storm would've happened anyways had Max done nothing.
It also causes Max to go to the bathroom where she witnesses the blue-haired girl being shot.

If Max hadn't had that vision and been unsettled by it, she wouldn't have been in a position to change the timeline in the first place...
Originally posted by rmsgrey:
Originally posted by Jack-alope:
Having the vision before using her powers is just foreshadowing of the story. It doesn't mean the storm would've happened anyways had Max done nothing.
It also causes Max to go to the bathroom where she witnesses the blue-haired girl being shot.

If Max hadn't had that vision and been unsettled by it, she wouldn't have been in a position to change the timeline in the first place...
I fixed my post since I realized it made no sense. I wrote it in a bad state (sick and with throbbing headache) :lisr_max_sweatdrop:
Egoistical mentality in it's finest..
One things that just didn't make sense to me were when she travels to her childhood and changes the past to save Chloe's father but apparently that didn't cause a storm in the past. Beyond that the sacrifice Chloe option felt kind of insulting, like the game was saying the whole thing was just a waste of my time as none of my decisions had any impact at all, it's why I didn't take that option and saved Chloe.
Originally posted by jcbunch4:
One things that just didn't make sense to me were when she travels to her childhood and changes the past to save Chloe's father but apparently that didn't cause a storm in the past. Beyond that the sacrifice Chloe option felt kind of insulting, like the game was saying the whole thing was just a waste of my time as none of my decisions had any impact at all, it's why I didn't take that option and saved Chloe.
The storm doesn't happen in that timeline because Chloe is alive.
Originally posted by Jack-alope:
The storm doesn't happen in that timeline because Chloe is alive.
Yeah, and it doesn't make sense. Why is Chloe dying more important then her father to the universe? The lack of a storm means Max has no reason to think using her powers or saving lives casues the storm and thus no reason to think going back and letting Chloe die would stop the storm
Originally posted by jcbunch4:
Originally posted by Jack-alope:
The storm doesn't happen in that timeline because Chloe is alive.
Yeah, and it doesn't make sense. Why is Chloe dying more important then her father to the universe? The lack of a storm means Max has no reason to think using her powers or saving lives casues the storm and thus no reason to think going back and letting Chloe die would stop the storm
Well because Chloe is more important than her father.
Spoilers!!:

The way it went for me was that I'd played the game a chapter an evening for 5 days. I'd jumped through all sorts of hoops to keep saving chloe's life. I lost Kate and that was heartbreaking. I really let myself get emotionally invested in Max's journey and when she ended up in the alternate timeline I finally broke and helped her die.

So when the final descision arrived I simply could not let her die again. The idea hurt too much, and I sacrificed the town.
Originally posted by RoguelikeMike:
As for me, I choose to think there's a third ending...
Double Exposure does end with Max choosing a third option - merging timelines, which, as it turns out, also solves the little storm problem...
Originally posted by RoguelikeMike:

With time travel, she really has infinite tries.

Did you not see in the time travel forward, the photos showed David Madsen tracking down and getting Jefferson arrested right before the nightmare sequence?
It makes more sense to save the town. And not be evil..
Saving the town does not only not make sense, it would not work.
If Friday Max uses the Blue Butterlfly to travel to Monday Max's body, Monday Max already knows about her timetravel powers.
So Friday Max in Monday Max's body idles in the bathroom while Nathan shoots Chloe. Then Friday Max travels back to Friday.
And Monday Max will rewind time to save Chloe, because that is what she came back into the bathroom in the first place.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 19 comments
Per page: 1530 50