I've lived in or near four college towns in my life. There's something about a university community--the athletic events and concerts, the hip campus town, the debates and public lectures, the ethnic and religious diversity. I hope I will always live in this kind of environment. Anyways, here is my ranking of these four towns, based on a number of categories that I find important. My grading system will use the * icon, with one star meaning "subpar" and five stars meaning "outstanding."
1.
Boulder, CO (University of Colorado) cool campus town: ****
hip coffee shops: ***
pretty campus: ****
good athletics: ***
outdoor recreation: *****
road trip factor: *****
concert venue: **
cultural diversity: ****
Commentary: We spent time in Boulder while living in Denver. Simply put, it's a great town. The cost of living is outrageous, so we will probably never live there. But it's perfect for short day trips. I went to a couple football and basketball games in Boulder while in Colorado. The facilities are adequate and the teams are about average, but there is considerable fan support and that makes for a fun environment. The campus is surrounded by beautiful flat iron mountains to the west, and so it's a very picturesque setting. There are lots of places to go hiking and take nature walks, and the Rocky Mountain National Park is only an hour away. Boulder is about a half hour from Denver, so it is very easy to visit the city. Also Boulder is a very diverse and liberal community, so it's an interesting place to go and watch people--especially at the Pearl Street Mall, a pedestrian mall near campus that is a must see for visitors: great restaurants, outdoor street peformers, coffee shops, unique shops, and so on.
2.
Fayetteville, AR (University of Arkansas) cool campus town: ***
hip coffee shops: **
pretty campus: **
good athletics: ***
outdoor recreation: ****
road trip factor: ***
concert venue: *
cultural diversity: **
Commentary: I've only lived in Fayetteville for a few months now, so maybe my opinion will change in the future. But so far I'm very impressed with what the "athens of the ozarks" has to offer. For one thing, it's located in a beautiful region of the state. Honestly I've never seen such breathtaking fall foliage in my life! And with the Ozark National Forest close by, there are some good options for taking short hikes and just enjoying nature's beauty. I'm a little disappointed that Razorback football is not more competitive, but the fan support is so intense and passionate down here that it still makes it interesting. Also Reynolds stadium is by far the best college football stadium I've seen in person. The road trip factor is a mixed bag. There are a number of larger cities within a few hours, like Kansas City, Tulsa, and Memphis, but they're still a long ways away, and not very convenient in the end. Probably my favorite part of Fayetteville is Dickson Street--there is a really great coffee shop called Common Grounds, and some decent restaurants as well. The Walton Arts Center is on Dickson Street as well, and I hear it brings in some Broadway musicals from time to time. Finally, since the Walton family will not allow concerts at Walton Arena--a big mistake in my opinion--residents are forced to go elsewhere to see any big name musical acts.
3.
Iowa City, IA (University of Iowa) cool campus town: ***
hip coffee shops: ****
pretty campus: **
good athletics: *****
outdoor recreation: **
road trip factor: **
concert venue: *
cultural diversity: ***
Commentary: You wouldn't think it, but Iowa City is a fairly cool town. Granted, it is in Iowa, and that has its limitations. But the town has a very unique personality, and that goes a long ways. It has a pretty neat pedestrian mall near campus, though it is overwhelmed with bars and such. But during the daytime, it is fun to walk around and get a cup of joe. Iowa City has a number of great local coffee shops, like Terrapins and the Java House, which make for a great place to sit and chat with friends. And you really can't beat Hawkeye sports. Even as a die hard Cyclone, I have to admit that Iowa is clearly a Hawkeye state. They have a particularly strong tradition in football (thanks to Hayden Fry) and Kinnick Stadium is a great venue for college football. Unfortunately, Iowa City is not a good venue for concerts, mainly because the population is so low. And road trips are difficult since Chicago is the closest large city around. But if you can tolerate the 4 hour drive, it is good for a weekend trip. As far as outdoor activities, there aren't many options, however Iowa City is well known for the Sugar Bottom bike trail, which is one of the best in the midwest. The campus itself is not very pretty and there aren't any good places to sit and read during warm weather, which is a big negative in my opinion.
4.
Ames, Iowa (Iowa State University) cool campus town: *
hip coffee shops: **
pretty campus: ****
good athletics: **
outdoor recreation: *
road trip factor: *
concert venue: ***
cultural diversity: **
Commentary: Since ISU is my alma mater, it pains me to put it in last place. But objectively this town is pretty boring, as far as college towns go. There is not much of a campus town to speak of, and there are almost no outdoor recreation options, unless you count the fairly unimpressive nearby Ledges State Park in Boone. The only options for road trips are Kansas City and Minneapolis, with each being more than 3 hours away, unless you consider Des Moines a viable road trip destination. The athletics are up and down: there are good years and bad years and I find ISU fans (including myself) to be far more fickle than their cross-state rivals. And Jack Trice Stadium is a pathetic excuse for a Big 12 football stadium. Having said all that, however, ISU does have a very pretty campus. And the fall is a great season to be a student and walk around campus. I always enjoyed sitting outside by the campanile to read between classes. Also Ames manages to get pretty decent concerts (or at least when I was there they did). This is probably because Des Moines never had a good venue to host a good show (not true anymore--they just built the Iowa Events Center). I've seen Aerosmith in Ames, as well as some top Christian acts, like DC Talk, Steven Curtis Chapman, Third Day, and so on. Finally, as a land-grant university that focuses primarily on agriculture and engineering, Ames is not particularly diverse. Yes, there are plenty of international students around. But the culture is fairly conservative and less interesting as a result.